Hilton Head Island Market Statistics
Median Home Price
$538,039
+34% vs national
Median Rent
$2,120/mo
+22% vs national
Property Tax Rate
0.57%
Price Change (1 Year)
-0.1%
Price Change (5 Year)
-0.3%
Price-to-Rent Ratio
21.1
+405% vs national avg
Income to Afford
$141,368
Days on Market
35 days
Data sources: Zillow, Tax Foundation. Last updated: 12/30/2025
Hilton Head Island Market Insights
Hilton Head Island's home prices have been relatively stable over the past year, changing just -0.1%. This stability can benefit both buyers seeking predictability and renters who aren't pressured to buy immediately.
Hilton Head Island's price-to-rent ratio of 21.1 is above the 20 threshold that typically indicates renting may be more financially advantageous. This doesn't mean you shouldn't buy, but the pure math favors renting in the short to medium term.
Home prices in Hilton Head Island are 34% above the national median of $402,356. This premium reflects strong demand, but means buyers need significantly more capital to enter the market.
Hilton Head Island benefits from a low property tax rate of just 0.57%. This makes homeownership more affordable on a monthly basis compared to high-tax states, improving the buy vs rent equation.
About This Analysis
These insights are generated based on current Hilton Head Island market data including median home prices, rental rates, property taxes, and historical appreciation. The analysis uses standard assumptions (20% down payment, 7% interest rate, 10-year horizon) for comparability. Your specific situation may differ. Use our calculator to run personalized numbers with Hilton Head Island data preloaded.
Average rent in Hilton Head Island in 2026
The typical Hilton Head Island rent is $2,120 per month, or $25,441 a year. That is 22% above the national typical rent, and rents here moved up (3.0%) over the past year. Against the median household income of $80,706, that rent takes about 32% of gross income, above the 30% rule of thumb.
Rent figure is the metro-level Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), a typical asking rent across unit sizes; a specific one-bedroom or three-bedroom will sit below or above it. For rent by ZIP code and bedroom count, see rent estimates for South Carolina.
What owning the median Hilton Head Island home costs per month
At the $538,039 median price, a buyer putting 20% down ($107,608) and financing the rest at 6.5% on a 30-year fixed loan pays about $3,581 a month all-in, versus $2,120 to rent. That is $1,461 a month more than renting, before counting the equity the owner builds or the return a renter could earn on the down payment.
| Monthly cost | 20% down | 10% down |
|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest (6.5%, 30-yr) | $2,721 | $3,061 |
| Property tax (0.57% of value) | $256 | $256 |
| Insurance and maintenance allowance | $605 | $605 |
| Mortgage insurance (PMI) | — | $202 |
| Total to own | $3,581 | $4,123 |
| Median rent | $2,120 | $2,120 |
Assumptions: 30-year fixed at 6.5%, insurance 0.35% and maintenance 1% of price per year, PMI 0.5% of the loan when the down payment is under 20%. Change any of them in the buy vs rent calculator, which also models appreciation, rent growth, taxes, and what the down payment earns if invested.
Hilton Head Island price-to-rent ratio: 21.1
Price-to-rent divides the median home price by a year of median rent: $538,039 ÷ $25,441 = 21.1. Put differently, buying the median home costs about 21 years of rent up front. Ratios under 15 usually favor buying, 15 to 20 is a toss-up, and above 20 the math tilts toward renting and investing the difference. The national ratio is about 19.3, so Hilton Head Island is more expensive to buy relative to rents than the typical US market.
The ratio is a screen, not a verdict. It ignores mortgage rates, property tax, how long you stay, and what home prices and rents do next, which is why the verdict above comes from the full model and not from this one number.
What would change the answer in Hilton Head Island
- Mortgage rates. A one-point drop from 6.5% to 5.5% cuts the 20%-down payment by $277 a month, to $3,305 all-in.
- How long you stay. The model does not find a break-even inside 30 years at today's Hilton Head Island prices, rents, and rates, which is why renting wins here unless prices fall or rents rise sharply.
- Price growth versus rent growth. Over the past year Hilton Head Island prices moved -0.1% and rents 3.0%. Rents outrunning prices is the pattern that eventually flips a market toward buying.
- Down payment size. Going from 20% to 10% down adds $542 a month in payment and PMI, but keeps $53,804 in your pocket to invest or hold as reserves.
Keep an eye on the Hilton Head Island market
Home prices, rents, and whether buying beats renting here. A short update when the data changes. Unsubscribe anytime.
Run Your Own Numbers
Our analysis uses standard assumptions. Your situation may be different. Use our full Buy vs Rent calculator to input your specific income, down payment, and financial goals.
Compare Nearby Markets
See how Hilton Head Island compares to other cities in South Carolina and the surrounding area.
| City | Median Home | Median Rent | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hilton Head Island(current) | $538,039 | $2,120 | Rent |
| Columbia | $238,959 | $1,544 | Rent |
| Spartanburg | $272,812 | $1,436 | Rent |
| Greenville | $329,079 | $1,598 | Rent |
Click on a city name to see its detailed rent vs buy analysis.
Frequently Asked Questions
The typical Hilton Head Island rent is $2,120 per month (metro-level Zillow Observed Rent Index), 22% above the national typical rent. Rents rose 3.0% over the past year. One-bedrooms rent below that figure and three-bedrooms above it; our rent estimates pages break it down by ZIP and bedroom count.
Our Methodology
Our rent vs buy analysis uses a comprehensive financial model that compares the total cost of homeownership against renting and investing the difference. Here's how we calculate each verdict:
1Buying Costs We Include
- Mortgage principal and interest (P&I)
- Property taxes (using local rates)
- Homeowner's insurance
- PMI (if down payment is less than 20%)
- Maintenance costs (1-2% of home value/year)
- Transaction costs (closing costs, realtor fees)
- Home appreciation over time
2Renting + Investing Assumptions
- Monthly rent with annual increases (~3%/year)
- Renter's insurance
- Down payment invested in stock market
- Monthly savings (buy cost - rent cost) invested
- 7% average annual stock market returns
- Investment growth over holding period
Standard Assumptions for City Analysis
Down Payment
20%
Interest Rate
7.0%
Loan Term
30 years
Time Horizon
10 years
How We Determine the Verdict
- Buy: When buying builds $20,000+ more wealth than renting over 10 years
- Rent: When renting + investing builds $20,000+ more wealth than buying over 10 years
- Toss-Up: When the difference is less than $20,000 either way, so lifestyle factors should guide your decision
Note: This analysis provides general guidance based on market averages. Individual results will vary based on specific property characteristics, negotiated prices, timing, and personal financial factors. Always run your own numbers with our full calculator for personalized results.
Explore More Cities
More in South Carolina
- Columbia$239k
- Spartanburg$273k
- Greenville$329k
- Charleston$598k
- North Charleston$598k
- Mount Pleasant$598k
- Rock Hill$386k
- Summerville$344k
Similar Price Range
- Phoenix, AZ$455k
- Austin, TX$467k
- Denver, CO$533k
- Washington, DC$573k
- Portland, OR$493k