Highest Cap Rate Markets for Rental Property (2026)

Cap rate measures the unlevered yield of a property, which makes it the cleanest way to compare markets without financing muddying the picture. These counties have the highest estimated cap rates in the country.

Top 50 markets, ranked

Indiana County, PA leads with a median price of $172,619, median rent of $1,913, and a 8.6% cap rate. Click any market for the full county report, or run its numbers in the calculator.

#MarketCap rateMedian priceMedian rentCash flowAnalyze
1Indiana County, PA8.6%$172,619$1,913$287Run numbers
2Lauderdale County, MS8.3%$121,229$1,291$168Run numbers
3Jefferson County, AR8.1%$81,305$840$96Run numbers
4Hinds County, MS7.7%$130,045$1,286$115Run numbers
5Baltimore City, MD7.6%$181,356$1,764$142Run numbers
6Vermilion Parish, LA7.3%$157,990$1,489$93Run numbers
7Walker County, AL7.2%$161,006$1,481$71Run numbers
8Iberia Parish, LA6.9%$145,862$1,290$30Run numbers
9Otsego County, NY6.8%$220,102$1,931$36Run numbers
10Vermilion County, IL6.8%$101,321$886$15Run numbers
11Taylor County, TX6.8%$228,744$1,995$29Run numbers
12Wayne County, NC6.6%$179,054$1,519-$5Run numbers
13Macon County, IL6.6%$124,658$1,059-$2Run numbers
14Robeson County, NC6.6%$136,515$1,149-$9Run numbers
15Saint Lawrence County, NY6.5%$149,753$1,239-$24Run numbers
16Jones County, MS6.5%$150,092$1,242-$24Run numbers
17Kanawha County, WV6.4%$151,294$1,238-$33Run numbers
18Montgomery County, AL6.3%$163,380$1,330-$41Run numbers
19Broome County, NY6.3%$201,781$1,640-$52Run numbers
20Lenoir County, NC6.3%$150,169$1,214-$43Run numbers
21Polk County, TX6.3%$174,922$1,411-$52Run numbers
22Coffee County, AL6.3%$177,245$1,421-$58Run numbers
23Wayne County, MI6.2%$175,631$1,402-$61Run numbers
24Garfield County, OK6.2%$140,570$1,116-$53Run numbers
25Hardin County, TX6.1%$230,858$1,817-$98Run numbers
26Wichita County, TX6.1%$169,452$1,325-$78Run numbers
27Dougherty County, GA6.0%$126,402$978-$64Run numbers
28Florence County, SC6.0%$204,585$1,574-$110Run numbers
29Potter County, TX6.0%$147,877$1,133-$83Run numbers
30Darlington County, SC6.0%$170,906$1,307-$97Run numbers
31Philadelphia County, PA5.9%$231,558$1,757-$140Run numbers
32Erie County, OH5.9%$240,422$1,812-$154Run numbers
33Livingston County, NY5.9%$247,627$1,865-$160Run numbers
34Saint Clair County, IL5.8%$177,683$1,333-$118Run numbers
35Lowndes County, MS5.8%$187,535$1,403-$127Run numbers
36Lea County, NM5.8%$196,513$1,469-$134Run numbers
37Caddo Parish, LA5.8%$151,157$1,118-$111Run numbers
38Terrebonne Parish, LA5.8%$179,856$1,331-$131Run numbers
39Steuben County, NY5.8%$172,442$1,274-$127Run numbers
40Cameron County, TX5.8%$204,554$1,509-$152Run numbers
41Chaves County, NM5.8%$171,293$1,263-$128Run numbers
42Huron County, OH5.7%$195,481$1,437-$149Run numbers
43Jefferson County, TX5.7%$176,616$1,290-$140Run numbers
44Saint Louis City, MO5.7%$176,514$1,287-$141Run numbers
45Orangeburg County, SC5.7%$162,517$1,180-$133Run numbers
46Belmont County, OH5.7%$132,616$963-$109Run numbers
47Washington County, OH5.6%$184,844$1,336-$155Run numbers
48Peoria County, IL5.6%$166,288$1,201-$141Run numbers
49Sumter County, SC5.6%$203,810$1,472-$172Run numbers
50Bibb County, GA5.6%$170,006$1,211-$154Run numbers

Showing the top 50 of 955 qualifying markets.

How this ranking is calculated

We scored 955 counties with a population over 50,000 and ranked them by capitalization rate, calculated as annual net operating income divided by median home price. Markets without both a median home price and a median rent are excluded, because cash flow cannot be estimated without both.

Every figure assumes a median-priced home rented at the local median rent, financed with 20 percent down on a 30-year loan at 7.40%, with closing costs at 3 percent of price and operating costs at 35 percent of rent. Operating costs cover taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancy, and management.

These are modeled estimates for comparing markets, not quotes on a specific property. A real deal turns on the individual property, its condition, and the actual rent it can command. Run any market that interests you through the calculator with real numbers before you make an offer.

Other ways to rank markets

The best market depends on what you are optimizing for. These rankings measure different things and produce different lists.

Narrow it down by state

Check a real deal in this market

These are median-priced estimates. Put in the actual price, rent, taxes, and financing for a property you are looking at and see whether it clears your bar.