Skip to page content

FARE Act and Voucher Broker Fees in NYC: Who Pays (2026)

Checked October 6, 20267 min readBy VoucherMatch Editorial Team
The white stone front of New York City Hall seen across the lawn of City Hall Park, framed by trees and an iron fence
New York City Hall, where the City Council sits, seen from City Hall Park in Manhattan, September 2025. Photo: Nielsoncaetanosalmeron, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Quick answerIn New York City, since June 11, 2025, the FARE Act (Local Law 119 of 2024) bars a landlord's broker, and any broker who publishes a listing with the landlord's permission, from charging the tenant a fee. Voucher tenants are covered like every other tenant, and a tenant may still hire and pay a broker of their own. As of October 6, 2026, no City document read says how the law treats a fee paid by a City program.
The numbers at a glance
  • June 11, 2025the day the FARE Act took effect
  • $0what a landlord's broker may collect from a tenant, voucher or not
  • $750DCWP's fixed penalty for a first fee violation; $2,000 from the third
  • 3 yearshow long the signed fee disclosure must be kept
  • July 13, 2026the Second Circuit affirmed the rulings against the brokers' challenge
  • 311say "Broker Fees" to file a complaint with DCWP

What the FARE Act Actually Says

A broker working for the landlord may not charge the tenant, and nobody may make a rental depend on the tenant hiring a broker. The law added sections 20-699.20 to 20-699.25 to the Administrative Code, and the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) enforces it.

The four rules in section 20-699.21
  • Landlord's agent"a landlord's agent shall not impose any fee on, or collect any fee from, a tenant related to the rental of residential real property"
  • Broker who listsany agent who publishes a listing "with the permission or authorization of the landlord" is under the same bar, and the law presumes a broker who publishes a listing has that permission. The presumption can be rebutted
  • Landlordthe landlord is in violation when its agent or its listing broker charges the tenant
  • No conditioning"No person shall condition the rental of residential real property on a tenant engaging any agent, including but not limited to a dual agent"

What it means: the law names no voucher program and has no carve-out for one, so a Section 8, CityFHEPS, FHEPS or HASA tenant is a "tenant" like any other.

Source: Local Law 119 of 2024, section 20-699.21(a), (b), (c) and (e).

What DCWP says the law leaves alone
  • Tenants "choosing to hire their own broker and pay broker fees"
  • Tenant brokers advertising their services, "so long as the broker does not condition the availability of specific units or identifiable inventory on the broker being hired by a tenant"
  • Landlords charging for background checks and credit checks under Real Property Law section 238-a(1)

What it means: the rule people repeat, "whoever hires the broker pays," is shorthand for this text.

Source: DCWP, Frequently Asked Questions: Broker Fees, 08/12/2025, questions 2 and 5.

Who Pays the Broker Fee: A Decision Diagram

The broker's relationship to the landlord decides it. Work down the list for the deal in front of you.

Decision diagram: who may be charged a broker fee on a New York City rental
  1. 1Did the broker publish the listing?The law presumes the landlord authorized it. The broker may not charge the tenant. The fee is between the broker and the landlord.
  2. 2Did the broker agree to act for the landlord, alone or cooperating with the listing agent?That is a "landlord's agent." The broker may not charge the tenant, and the landlord is liable if it happens.
  3. 3Was the tenant told the unit is available only through one broker, or only to people who hire a broker?That is conditioning, a violation by whoever does it, including for a dual agent.
  4. 4Did the tenant choose to hire the broker to find a home, with no unit held back to force the choice?The law does not stop that tenant from paying their own broker.
  5. 5Is the tenant using a voucher?Steps 1 to 4 apply unchanged. Then read the program's own form: HRA's and NYCHA's fee forms each have the broker certify that the tenant was asked for nothing beyond an application fee charged to all applicants.
  6. 6Is a City program paying a fee on this rental?No document read says how the FARE Act applies to it. Get the agency's answer in writing before counting on the check.

What it means: on a voucher rental the tenant-fee answer is the same as on any rental, and the only unpublished piece is step 6.

Source: Local Law 119, sections 20-699.20 and 20-699.21; DCWP FAQ, questions 2 to 5; HRA-121; NYCHA 059.853. Diagram compiled by VoucherMatch.

What the Law Requires in a Listing

Every listing must show every fee the tenant will pay, and the tenant must sign an itemized fee disclosure before the lease.

A six-story tan brick apartment building with red fire escapes and cars parked along the street in front
An apartment building on Ocean Avenue in Brooklyn, August 2022. Photo: GK tramrunner RU, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
FARE Act listing and disclosure requirements, New York City, in effect since June 11, 2025, with DCWP's first-violation penalty
RequirementWhoWhenSectionFirst violation
No listing may represent that fees must be paid in a way the law forbids"No person"When the listing is posted20-699.21(d)$750
Disclose "in a clear and conspicuous manner any fee to be paid by the prospective tenant"Every listingIn the listing itself20-699.22(a)$375
Give the tenant an itemized written disclosure of any fees owed to the landlord, or to anyone else at the landlord's direction, with a short description of eachLandlord or landlord's agentBefore the rental agreement is signed20-699.22(b)$375
Have the tenant sign that disclosure, give the tenant a copy and keep the signed originalLandlord or landlord's agentSigned before the lease; kept 3 years20-699.22(b)$375

What it means: the disclosure is owed on a voucher rental even when the tenant's fees are zero or a single application fee, because the law has no exception by source of rent.

Source: Local Law 119 of 2024, sections 20-699.21(d) and 20-699.22; penalties from DCWP's adopted rule, 6 RCNY 6-89. Table compiled by VoucherMatch.

On a CityFHEPS rental the disclosure sits beside HRA's own paperwork, which the landlord packet checklist lists form by form.

Penalties and How to Complain to DCWP

DCWP issues a summons, the case is heard at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH), and a sustained charge brings a civil penalty and possibly restitution of the illegal fee. The law sets maximums: $1,000 for a first fee violation and $2,000 for each later one within two years, and $500 then $1,000 for disclosure violations (section 20-699.23).

DCWP fixed penalties under the FARE Act by number of violations within two years, dollars (6 RCNY 6-89, effective July 10, 2025)
Fee, conditioning or listing-content violation (20-699.21)Disclosure violation (20-699.22)
View the data table
Violation countFee, conditioning or listing-content violation (20-699.21)Disclosure violation (20-699.22)
First$750$375
Second$1,800$900
Third and later$2,000$1,000

What it means: each provision charged counts as a separate violation, and a respondent who does not appear pays the default amount: $1,000 on a first fee violation and $500 on a first disclosure violation.

Source: DCWP Notice of Adoption, 6 RCNY 6-89.

Three ways to act on a violation
  • OnlineDCWP's complaint form, linked from its FARE Act page. DCWP asks for evidence such as text messages, screenshots and receipts, and the broker's name and contact information
  • Phonecall 311 and say "Broker Fees" (212-639-9675 from outside the city), per DCWP's renter brochure
  • Courtanyone alleging a violation may sue, and a court may order compensatory, injunctive and declaratory relief (section 20-699.24)
Key pointIn the law's first year DCWP received more than 2,000 complaints and inquiries and issued 74 summonses alleging 100 violations. About $27,000 in penalties and about $15,000 in refunds to tenants followed, according to figures DCWP gave The City (June 8, 2026).

A broker who turns a voucher holder away is a separate matter, handled by the Commission on Human Rights: see how to report voucher discrimination in NYC.

Where the Court Challenge Stands (REBNY v. City of New York)

The law is in effect, and the challengers have lost at both levels so far. One claim is still pending in the trial court.

The granite columns of a courthouse portico seen from below, with the words United States Court House carved above them
The Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse on Foley Square in Manhattan, home of the Second Circuit, June 2018. Photo: aismallard, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Real Estate Board of New York v. City of New York, S.D.N.Y. No. 24-cv-9678 and 2d Cir. No. 25-1506
  • November 13, 2024the City Council passed the FARE Act, 42 to 8.
  • June 10, 2025Judge Ronnie Abrams dismissed the First Amendment and state preemption claims and denied a preliminary injunction. The Contracts Clause claim was not dismissed.
  • June 11, 2025the law took effect.
  • November 3, 2025the appeal was argued.
  • July 13, 2026the Second Circuit affirmed. It held the listing rule satisfies the test for commercial speech regulation and that the plaintiffs had not shown they were likely to win on the Contracts Clause.
  • July 14, 2026The Real Deal reported that the Contracts Clause claim remains, covering tenant-pays listing agreements signed before December 13, 2024, and quoted REBNY's president saying the group "will explore pathways to continue our legal challenge."

What it means: no court has blocked the law at any point, so brokers and landlords are bound by it today.

Source: Second Circuit opinion, No. 25-1506, decided July 13, 2026; The Real Deal, July 14, 2026.

VoucherMatch found no court order or report dated after July 14, 2026; later filings may exist. The opinion does not discuss vouchers or fees paid by a government program.

What It Means for Each Voucher Program

Each program's own paper already limits what a broker can ask the tenant for, and none of it mentions the FARE Act. Amounts, conditions and forms are in the sister article, does CityFHEPS pay a broker fee, which has the full fee table by program.

What each New York City program's document says about fees charged to the tenant, read October 6, 2026
Program and documentWhat it says about the tenantMentions the FARE Act?
CityFHEPS, and FHEPS shelter exits: HRA-121 (06/30/2021)The HRA check "represents the entire broker's fee." The broker certifies no fees were requested from the tenant "other than, if applicable, an incidental apartment application fee required of all tenant applicants"No. Predates the law
FHEPS community moves: W-147JJ (Rev. 4/28/11)The amount is the entire fee and the applicant "is not responsible for any monies in excess of the amount issued"No. Predates the law
NYCHA Section 8: form 059.853 (07/07/23)Same certification as HRA-121. The form covers a broker who finds the unit or who "exclusively represents the owner"No. Predates the law
HPD Section 8: program FAQ"tenants are required to pay for their own security deposits and brokers' fees if applicable"No
HASANo broker fee document published by HRANot applicable

What it means: where a City form applies, the broker has signed that the tenant was not charged. HPD's sentence was written without reference to the law, and since June 11, 2025 a landlord's broker may not charge an HPD tenant either.

Sources: HRA-121; W-147JJ; NYCHA 059.853; HPD Section 8 FAQ.

HRA tells CityFHEPS tenants the same thing: "Brokers should not ask you to pay any additional broker fees because DSS is paying your broker's fee" (DSS-7r, page 9). For HASA, see HASA broker requirements.

Does FHEPS Pay Broker Fees?

Yes, at two levels, according to HRA's forms. FHEPS was formerly called FEPS.

The two FHEPS broker fees
  • Family leaving HRA or DHS shelteran enhanced fee of up to 15% of the annual rent, requested on HRA-121, "for as long as funding remains available" (HRA-146q, page 1)
  • Community moveform W-147JJ, where the amount "is 50% of the monthly rent," issued as a Cash Assistance allowance (HRA's FHEPS page)

Either way the form bars a charge to the tenant above HRA's payment. The rest of the paperwork is in the FHEPS landlord packet.

Does Section 8 pay a broker fee?

Only in limited cases at NYCHA and HPD, and each agency's rule is different. Federal regulations were not checked for this article, and neither was the State's program (HCR).

Section 8 broker fees: what NYCHA and HPD publish
  • NYCHA, adopted plan (May 2026)"NYCHA will pay broker fees only in the case where the tenant or a family member requires a reasonable accommodation for a disability" (Administrative Plan, section XV.J)
  • NYCHA, older form still onlineform 059.853, dated 07/07/23, offers up to 15% of annualized rent for a newly issued voucher and excludes transfers. NYCHA's broker fee FAQ and Owner Incentives pages return "page not found," and nine current NYCHA Section 8 pages read for this article do not mention a broker fee
  • NYCHA Emergency Housing Vouchersthe plan lists a "Broker's fee (up to 15% of annual rent)" among housing search supports (section on EHV service fee uses)
  • HPD"HPD does not typically pay any moving fees, real estate broker fees or security deposits" (Section 8 Move FAQ, question 12)
  • HPD exceptions in printa 15% broker's fee in its Housing Choice mobility pilot (program guide), and brokers' fees named among supports for Emergency Housing Vouchers and the Community Choice Demonstration (HPD Administrative Plan, April 2025)
Watch outConfirm the NYCHA 15% broker fee before counting on it.NYCHA's 2023 form and its May 2026 plan do not match. The plan is the adopted policy. VoucherMatch could not confirm that NYCHA still pays the form's 15% fee for new voucher holders, so ask the Housing Navigation Unit hotline printed on the form, 212-306-3570, before relying on it.

The two agencies are compared in HPD vs NYCHA Section 8, and Emergency Housing Vouchers are winding down: see the EHV transition guide.

Who pays the broker's fee on a Section 8 emergency move?

Neither NYCHA nor HPD publishes a broker fee for an emergency transfer. NYCHA's 2023 form excludes "voucher holders who are transferring," and its plan limits broker fees to reasonable accommodations. HPD's move FAQ says a tenant who needs help with broker fees may bring the Notice of HPD Approval to Move to HRA "to apply for a one-shot deal."

The FARE Act still applies: a broker who listed the unit or works for the landlord cannot bill the tenant, so that fee is the landlord's. The tenant owes a fee only to a broker the tenant chose to hire. Steps and forms are in Section 8 emergency transfer in NYC, and HRA's grant is explained in the one-shot deal guide.

The Open Question: Can a Landlord's Broker Take the City's Fee?

No official source read for this article answers it. The law's text bars imposing a fee on, or collecting a fee from, "a tenant," and says nothing about a fee a government agency pays.

What has been published on City-paid fees and the FARE Act
  • June 30, 2021HRA-121 last revised. HRA requests the check "on behalf of" the tenant. The form has not changed since the law passed.
  • July 7, 2023NYCHA's form dated. It lets the broker tick "Voucher Holder" or "Owner" as the party represented.
  • June 27, 2025City Limits reported that the City "did not respond by the time of publication" on whether it would keep contributing to broker's fees on CityFHEPS leases (City Limits).
  • August 12, 2025DCWP's FAQ issued. Its nine questions do not address a fee paid by a City agency.
  • April 1, 2026the CityFHEPS Landlord Package revised. The landlord still represents that "The premises cannot be rented without the services of" the named broker (DSS-8f, page 6).
  • June 8, 2026The City reported that the law's sponsor "pointed to" $6.7 million in annual HRA savings "from avoiding paying broker fees for voucher-holders." No HRA document stating that figure, or the policy behind it, was found.

What it means: HRA's forms read the same as before the law, one press report carries a savings figure with no document behind it, and no agency has said in writing which requests it approves. VoucherMatch draws no legal conclusion from that record.

Separately, a cap of one month's rent on the CityFHEPS fee was reported in June 2026 and appears on no HRA form. The CityFHEPS broker fee article tracks it.

The Clean Way to Work Voucher Deals Now

Do the things the law and the program forms spell out, and get the unpublished part answered in writing.

Before the lease on a voucher rental
  • Take no fee from the tenant if you listed the unit or act for the landlord
  • If the tenant hired you, keep the signed, dated agreement showing the tenant chose to
  • Never tell a voucher holder a unit is available only through your office
  • Put every tenant-paid fee in the listing, clearly
  • Have the tenant sign the itemized fee disclosure before the lease, give a copy and keep yours for three years
  • If a City fee is expected, ask the housing specialist or the agency which form applies, what amount is approved and whether your role in the deal qualifies, and keep the reply
  • Make the broker details on HRA-121 match page 6 of the Landlord Package

Payment mechanics by program are in how brokers get paid on voucher deals in NYC, and licensing is in how to become a CityFHEPS broker.

Watch outBrokers may not refuse a CityFHEPS voucher either.HRA also tells CityFHEPS tenants that a landlord or broker may not refuse the voucher. Can a landlord refuse Section 8 in NYC covers the source of income rules.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a voucher tenant choose to pay me a fee?

Under the FARE Act, yes, if the tenant chose to hire you. Where HRA or NYCHA pays a fee, the form you sign says the check is the entire fee and that you asked the tenant for nothing beyond a standard application fee.

Does CityFHEPS pay a broker fee?

HRA's forms say yes, up to 15% of the annual rent on HRA-121, while funding remains. Who qualifies and the reported cut are in the CityFHEPS broker fee article.

What are the exceptions?

The law's text has two: fees allowed by Real Property Law section 238-a(1), which DCWP describes as background and credit checks, and a co-op corporation leasing to its own shareholder. DCWP adds that a tenant may choose to hire and pay a broker.

Does FARE apply to rooms and SROs?

Not answered by DCWP. The law covers a "dwelling unit," which the Housing Maintenance Code defines as "any residential accommodation in a multiple dwelling or private dwelling." DCWP's FAQ does not mention rooms.

What if the tenant signed with me before June 11, 2025?

DCWP says the ban "may not apply to a contractual obligation for a tenant to pay a fee for a broker's services that arose before June 11, 2025, depending on the particular circumstances under which the obligation arose."

Where do tenants report a FARE violation?

To DCWP: online, or by calling 311 and saying "Broker Fees." HRA tells CityFHEPS tenants to report a refused voucher or a side deal to the Commission on Human Rights at 212-416-0197.

Next step: pull one active voucher listing and check it against the table above: every tenant-paid fee shown, no "broker fee" line for a unit you listed, and a blank itemized disclosure ready for signature.

Have a unit to fill? Owners and brokers can list a property on VoucherMatch, where renters search apartments that accept Section 8.

TipBrokers who work with voucher holders can join VoucherMatch's broker directory.

How this article was checked

Last checked: October 6, 2026, against Local Law 119 of 2024 (Administrative Code sections 20-699.20 to 20-699.25), DCWP's FARE Act page (updated 6/02/2026) and broker fee FAQ (08/12/2025), DCWP's penalty rule (6 RCNY 6-89, effective July 10, 2025), the Second Circuit's opinion in Real Estate Board of New York v. City of New York (No. 25-1506, July 13, 2026), HRA-121 (rev. 06/30/2021), W-147JJ (Rev. 4/28/11), HRA-146q (rev. 08/20/2025), DSS-8f (rev. 04/01/2026), NYCHA's Administrative Plan (May 2026) and form 059.853 (07/07/23), and HPD's Section 8 FAQs. General information, not legal advice.

Sources for this article (23)
  1. Local Law 119 of 2024 (intro.nyc)
  2. DCWP, Frequently Asked Questions: Broker Fees, 08/12/2025 (nyc.gov)
  3. HRA-121 (nyc.gov)
  4. NYCHA 059.853 (nyc.gov)
  5. DCWP's adopted rule, 6 RCNY 6-89 (rules.cityofnewyork.us)
  6. complaint form (a866-dcwpbp.nyc.gov)
  7. FARE Act page (nyc.gov)
  8. renter brochure (nyc.gov)
  9. The City (June 8, 2026) (thecityreporter.nyc)
  10. Second Circuit opinion, No. 25-1506, decided July 13, 2026 (ww3.ca2.uscourts.gov)
  11. The Real Deal, July 14, 2026 (therealdeal.com)
  12. W-147JJ (nyc.gov)
  13. HPD Section 8 FAQ (nyc.gov)
  14. DSS-7r, page 9 (nyc.gov)
  15. HRA-146q, page 1 (nyc.gov)
  16. HRA's FHEPS page (nyc.gov)
  17. Administrative Plan, section XV.J (nyc.gov)
  18. Section 8 Move FAQ, question 12 (nyc.gov)
  19. program guide (nyc.gov)
  20. HPD Administrative Plan, April 2025 (nyc.gov)
  21. City Limits (citylimits.org)
  22. DSS-8f, page 6 (nyc.gov)
  23. Housing Maintenance Code (nyc.gov)
Share:

Stay Updated on Housing

Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.

VoucherMatch Editorial Team

Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected

Related Articles

Explore the NYC broker workspace

Keep your client’s housing search moving with practical guides and the right workspace.