Can a Landlord Refuse Section 8 in NYC? The Law in 2026

Quick answerNo. In New York City, as of October 2026, a landlord, managing agent or broker may not refuse a tenant because the rent will be paid with Section 8, CityFHEPS, HASA or another lawful source of income (NYC Administrative Code section 8-107(5)). Since February 15, 2021 the City rule has no building-size threshold. Two narrow owner-occupied exemptions remain. The Commission on Human Rights can impose a civil penalty of up to $250,000 for a willful violation.
- 2008year the City added "lawful source of income" to its Human Rights Law
- February 15, 2021date the City's five-or-fewer-unit exception ended
- $250,000top City civil penalty for a willful violation
- $125,000top City civil penalty otherwise
- 1 yeardeadline for a complaint to the City Commission
- 3 yearsdeadline for a State Division complaint or a court case
What the Law Says
City law makes it an unlawful discriminatory practice to refuse to rent, to offer worse terms, or to say a unit is unavailable "because of any lawful source of income" of the applicant. The text is Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(a)(1). Section 8-107(5)(a)(2) bars ads, application forms and inquiries that express any limitation as to lawful source of income.
Section 8-102 defines the term. It "includes, but is not limited to, child support, alimony, foster care subsidies, income derived from social security, or any form of federal, state, or local public assistance or housing assistance including, but not limited to, section 8 vouchers, whether or not such income or credit is paid or attributed directly to a landlord."
- Owners, landlords and their staff"the owner, lessor, lessee, sublessee, assignee, or managing agent of, or other person having the right to sell, rent or lease ... a housing accommodation ... or any agent or employee thereof" (section 8-107(5)(a))
- Brokers and salespeople"any real estate broker, real estate salesperson or employee or agent thereof," including a refusal to negotiate a rental (section 8-107(5)(c))
- Vouchers named by the CommissionSection 8, SSI, HASA, CityFHEPS and GI Bill housing allowances, "among others"
What it means: the Commission's landlord FAQ tells owners they answer for anyone who processes applications for their units, employee or not.
Source: NYC Administrative Code sections 8-102 and 8-107(5), as posted by the Commission on Human Rights; Commission source of income page.
- March 26, 2008Local Law 10 adds lawful source of income to the City Human Rights Law
- April 12, 2019New York State amends its Human Rights Law to cover lawful source of income statewide
- November 17, 2020Local Law 119 is signed. It widens the City definition and repeals the small-building exception
- February 15, 2021Local Law 119 takes effect
- January 1, 2025the Fair Chance Housing Act (Local Law 24 of 2024) takes effect and limits criminal background checks
- March 5, 2026a State appeals court rules against part of the State law, for Section 8 only. The Attorney General's appeal is at the Court of Appeals
What it means: a rule a landlord learned before 2021 may no longer be the rule.
Source: Commission on Human Rights amendments page and Local Law 119 of 2020; NYS Attorney General source of income page; Commons West decision.
City law and State law side by side
Two laws apply inside the five boroughs.
| City law | State law | |
|---|---|---|
| Who is covered | Owners, lessors, managing agents, their agents and employees, brokers and salespeople (Admin. Code 8-107(5)(a) and (c)) | Owners, lessees, managing agents, their agents and employees, brokers and salespeople (Executive Law 296(5)(a) and (c)) |
| Exemptions | Unadvertised unit in an owner-occupied two-family building; a room in the owner's or occupant's home. Neither applies to publicly-assisted housing (8-107(5)(a)(4)) | Owner-occupied two-family building; a room rented by the occupant or resident owner; all rooms rented to one sex; certain senior housing (296(5)(a)(4)) |
| Where to file | NYC Commission on Human Rights, 212-416-0197 | NYS Division of Human Rights, 844-697-3471 |
| Deadline | 1 year to the Commission (8-109(e)); 3 years in court (8-502(d)) | 3 years (Executive Law 297(5)) |
| Penalty | Up to $125,000, or $250,000 if willful, wanton or malicious (8-126(a)), plus damages and attorney's fees (8-120) | Fines up to $50,000, or $100,000 if willful, wanton or malicious; compensatory damages; punitive damages up to $10,000 in housing cases (297(4)(c)) |
What it means: an owner who fits a State exemption can still be covered by the City law, and the reverse.
Source: NYC Administrative Code, Title 8, chapter 1 and chapter 5; Executive Law sections 296 and 297 on nysenate.gov; phone numbers from the Commission's source of income page and the Division's reporting page. Compiled by VoucherMatch.
Watch outA State appeals court ruled the State Section 8 protection unconstitutional.On March 5, 2026 the Appellate Division, Third Department, affirmed judgments declaring the State provision "facially unconstitutional to the extent that it makes it an unlawful discriminatory practice to refuse to rent or lease housing accommodations to any person, or group of persons, because their source of income includes Section 8 vouchers." On May 21, 2026 the Court of Appeals denied a stay motion "as unnecessary", citing CPLR 5519(a)(1). The opinion concerns Executive Law 296(5)(a)(1) and does not mention the City's Administrative Code. VoucherMatch found no Court of Appeals decision as of October 7, 2026. The Commons West article follows the case.

Exceptions to the Law
Only two exemptions are written into the City law, and neither depends on how many units the owner has.
- Owner-occupied two-family buildinga rental "in a building which contains housing accommodations for not more than two families living independently of each other," if the owner or members of the owner's family live in one of them, "and if the available housing accommodation has not been publicly advertised, listed, or otherwise offered to the general public."
- A room in someone's home"a room or rooms in a housing accommodation," if the rental is by the occupant, or by the owner and the owner or the owner's family live there.
What it means: both exemptions are written for housing "other than a publicly-assisted housing accommodation," and the two-family exemption is lost once the unit is publicly advertised.
Does the law apply to small buildings?
Yes. Since February 15, 2021 the City protection does not turn on unit count. Before that date, section 8-107(5)(o) excluded housing with five or fewer units unless the owner had another building of six or more. Local Law 119 of 2020 reads: "Paragraph (o) of subdivision 5 of section 8-107 of the administrative code of the city of New York is REPEALED."
Watch outTwo official documents still show outdated unit thresholds.Two official documents still show old thresholds. The Commission's broker FAQ (file dated January 2020, before the repeal) says owners with "at least one (1) building of six (6) or more dwelling units" are covered. HRA's apartment hunting page says "at least three (3) units." Neither matches the statute, or the Commission's current page, which says "regardless of number of units in the property."
- 1Is it a home in the five boroughs offered for rent?If yes, the City law's housing section applies. Go to step 2.
- 2Is it publicly-assisted housing?If yes, neither exemption is available. If no, go to step 3.
- 3Is it a room inside a home where the renting occupant, the owner or the owner's family lives?If yes, the room exemption applies. If no, go to step 4.
- 4Is it in a building for no more than two families, with the owner or the owner's family living in one unit?If no, the rental is covered. If yes, go to step 5.
- 5Was the unit publicly advertised, listed or otherwise offered to the general public?If yes, the rental is covered. If no, the two-family exemption applies.
What it means: a six-unit building, a three-family house and a single condo rented by its owner all end at "covered." The Commission tells anyone unsure about an exemption to call 212-416-0197.
Source: VoucherMatch's reading of Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(a)(4), in force since February 15, 2021.
The State's two-family exemption has no advertising condition for the refusal itself, but it ends "if there is unlawful discriminatory conduct pursuant to subparagraph three," the State's advertising rule (Executive Law 296(5)(a)(4)).
What Landlords Cannot Do
A landlord, agent or broker cannot refuse, advertise against, steer or set different terms for an applicant because of a voucher. The agencies' guidance says what that looks like in practice.

| Practice | What the agency says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| "No vouchers," "no programs," or a stated preference for tenants without vouchers, in an ad or message | Unlawful to publish | Admin. Code 8-107(5)(a)(2); Commission source of income page |
| "This building does not take vouchers" | "Evidence of source of income discrimination" | Commission tenant FAQ |
| Minimum income, such as $68,000 a year or 43 times the rent | "A violation of the Law to impose any additional income requirements" where the tenant's share is calculated from income | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Guarantor or co-signer | "You may not require guarantors or co-signers" | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Minimum credit score | No rejection on credit if the voucher covers 100% of the rent. Otherwise "requiring a specific credit score ... is evidence of discrimination" | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Not completing agency paperwork or the inspection | Owners must comply "with program obligations, such as filling out all paperwork and ensuring the unit passes applicable housing quality inspections" | Commission landlord FAQ; State Division Section 8 page |
| A voucher "waitlist," or opening only some units to voucher holders | "Steering applicants to specific buildings or units is a violation" | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Section 8 but not HASA; "working Section 8" only | "Accepting only some vouchers or programs also violates the Law" | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Six months' rent up front; fees or "hold" deposits above $20 | Evidence of discrimination | Commission tenant FAQ |
| "No longer available," or silence, once the voucher is mentioned | Evidence if a caller with job income is then allowed to apply | Commission tenant FAQ; State Division ("ghosting") |
| Stalling until the unit is leased; raising the rent only for voucher holders | "May be source of income discrimination, depending on the specific circumstances" | State Division Section 8 page |
| Telling a sitting tenant who gets a voucher to move | "Owners may not refuse to accept payments from voucher or subsidy programs" | Commission landlord FAQ |
What it means: a rule applied to every applicant can still be a violation when the voucher program has already set what the tenant pays.
Source: Commission on Human Rights landlord FAQ and tenant FAQ, March 2023; NYS Division of Human Rights, Section 8 page.
Unless exempt, owners must also accept security deposit vouchers. For brokers, the CityFHEPS broker article covers the State fair housing notice rules, and the FARE Act article covers who pays the fee.
What Landlords Can Do
A landlord may still screen on lawful criteria. The State Division's notice to housing providers puts it this way: "It is not unlawful to ask about income, only to discriminate based on lawful sources of income."
| Step | Limit | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Ask about income and its source, and ask for documents | Must "accept all lawful sources of income equally" | State Division notice |
| Credit inquiry when the tenant pays part of the rent | Case by case, no fixed score. Let the applicant show they can pay their share, and give a written explanation of a credit-based decision | Commission landlord FAQ |
| Background or credit check fee | Actual cost or $20, whichever is less. Waived if the applicant supplies a check from the past 30 days. Collectable only with a copy of the report and the receipt | Real Property Law 238-a(1)(b) |
| Criminal background check | Only after a written conditional offer. Reviewable: felonies within 5 years, misdemeanors within 3 years, sex offense registry. Five business days for the applicant to respond | Admin. Code 8-107(5)(o); Commission Fair Chance Housing page |
| Housing court history | Not a lawful ground. Checking court records and then refusing creates a rebuttable presumption of a violation | Real Property Law 227-f |
| Program eligibility rules in publicly-assisted housing | Allowed where federal or State law requires them | Admin. Code 8-107(5)(m) |
What it means: the screening left to a landlord is handled one application at a time, with the reasons written down.
Source: as linked in each row; statutes read October 7, 2026.
ExampleThe rent is $2,000. The voucher pays $1,500 and sets the tenant's share at $500 from the tenant's income. These figures are hypothetical. The Commission's landlord FAQ treats any added income requirement for this applicant as a violation, whether a "40 times the rent" rule is measured against $2,000 or against $500.
How to screen Section 8 tenants goes through the process step by step.
Consequences of Discrimination
The City can order damages, attorney's fees, the apartment itself and a civil penalty. Penalties are paid into the City's general fund (section 8-127). Damages go to the tenant.
View the data table
| Case and date | Damages to tenants | Civil penalty |
|---|---|---|
| New American Realty Corp., decision August 3, 2026 | $101,816 | $45,000 |
| NY Pyramid Group Corp., decision August 3, 2026 | $75,000 | $50,000 |
| Compass Inc., settlement, January to June 2025 | $50,000 | $110,000 |
| Compass Realty, settlement, July to December 2025 | $20,000 | $50,000 |
What it means: in both August 2026 decisions the respondents were brokers. The New American figure includes $36,816 for the value of a lost voucher. The Compass Inc. damages figure is VoucherMatch's sum of two $25,000 awards.
Source: Commission on Human Rights, 2026 decisions and orders and 2025 settlements.
- August 2024, Parkchester Preservation Management. $1 million in civil penalties and 850 apartments set aside, over minimum income requirements (Mayor's Office)
- January to June 2025, CitiHabitats. $270,000 in damages and penalties across four complaints
- January to May 2026, Bond NY. $10,000 in damages and a $30,000 application assistance fund after an agent insisted on a credit score
- January to May 2026, a landlord who would not fill out paperwork for a sitting tenant. $35,000 in damages, $5,000 in penalties, and all new vacancies set aside for two years (2026 settlements)
- 2025, Urban Pads LLC, State Division of Human Rights. $40,000 to the Fair Housing Justice Center (Division release)
The Commission's page also describes cases against Abeco Management, Bronstein Properties and REM Residential, without dates. For brokers, the tenant FAQ says the City can "report licensed brokers & salespeople who violate the law to the New York State Licensing Division." NYC brokers fined for voucher discrimination reads the settlements in detail.
How Tenants Document Discrimination
Tenants are told by the Commission to build a dated record, and the Commission runs its own tests. Its tenant FAQ advises applicants to:
- Photograph or screenshot the ad at once
- Save texts and emails somewhere other than the phone
- Record calls and conversations "when possible," which it describes as permissible in New York
- Have a friend with job income ask whether the unit is still available
- Ask for a letter giving the reason for a rejection and a copy of the background check
The Commission says it uses "matched pair, in-person, telephone, and online testing." Complaints can also start without a tenant: under section 8-109(c) the Commission "may itself make, sign and file a verified complaint."
Filing steps, deadlines and what each agency does next are in how to report voucher discrimination in NYC.
Best Practices for Compliance
Handle a voucher applicant with the same written process as anyone else.
- Ads and listings. no wording that refuses or disfavors any program
- First contact. show the unit and give the application on the same terms as any caller
- One list. no separate voucher units, buildings or waitlist
- Every program. Section 8, CityFHEPS, FHEPS, HASA and security deposit vouchers treated alike
- Income. no minimum income or guarantor where the program sets the tenant's share from income
- Credit. no check where the voucher pays 100%. Otherwise a case-by-case review with written reasons
- Fees. $20 or actual cost for the check, with the report and receipt given to the applicant, and nothing more until the agency approves the move-in
- Criminal history. nothing asked before a written conditional offer, then the Fair Chance Housing steps
- Paperwork and inspection. complete the agency's forms and get the unit through inspection
- Agents. tell every broker and super the rules. If one refuses a voucher, the Commission's FAQ says to end the relationship, keep a log and report it at 212-416-0197
- Still vacant after a wrongful denial. the FAQ's "best practice is to offer the otherwise-qualified applicant the apartment"
What it means: this is the Commission's own guidance to owners, in the order a rental happens.
Source: Commission on Human Rights landlord FAQ, March 2023; Real Property Law 238-a; Commission Fair Chance Housing page.
The forms themselves are in the CityFHEPS landlord packet checklist and CityFHEPS landlord requirements.
The Business Case for Accepting Vouchers
The sourced case is about cost: the cases above ended in five- and six-figure sums. The Commission said on June 15, 2026 that its settlements that year had created 70 new apartments set aside for voucher holders (press release). NYCHA's payment schedule covers when Section 8 pays.
Resources
Check a rule against the statute and the agencies' own pages before acting on it.
- NYC Human Rights Law, chapter 1 and the Commission's source of income page, which links its three FAQs
- Commission report form; phone 212-416-0197
- NYS Division of Human Rights, reporting page; phone 844-697-3471
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal for a landlord to say "no Section 8" in NYC? Yes. Section 8-107(5)(a) of the City's Administrative Code bars refusing to rent because of lawful source of income, and section 8-102 names Section 8 vouchers.
Can a landlord accept Section 8 but refuse CityFHEPS? No, according to the Commission on Human Rights: "Accepting only some vouchers or programs also violates the Law."
Can a landlord require a voucher holder to earn 3 times the rent? Not where the program sets the tenant's share from income, as Section 8 does.
- Income: the Commission calls any added income requirement a violation in that case
- Guarantors: may not be required either
Can a landlord run a credit check on a Section 8 applicant? Only if the tenant pays part of the rent, and without a fixed minimum score. The limits are under What Landlords Can Do.
Are any NYC landlords exempt from accepting vouchers? Only two, set out under Exceptions to the Law.
- Two-family: an unadvertised unit in an owner-occupied two-family building
- Room: a room in someone's home
Does the law apply to buildings with fewer than six units? Yes. Local Law 119 of 2020 repealed the five-or-fewer-unit exception, effective February 15, 2021.
What is the penalty for refusing a voucher in NYC, and how do I report it? Up to $125,000, or $250,000 for a willful, wanton or malicious act, plus damages and attorney's fees.
- Report: call the Commission at 212-416-0197
- Steps: the reporting guide covers filing and deadlines
- Next step for landlords: read your current listing and application form against the table of refused practices, then list the unit on VoucherMatch
- Tenants: browse listings from landlords who take vouchers or Section 8 apartments by borough
How this article was checked
Last checked: October 7, 2026, against the NYC Human Rights Law as posted by the Commission on Human Rights (Administrative Code Title 8); Local Law 119 of 2020; the Commission's source of income page, FAQs, Fair Chance Housing page, settlement and decision pages; New York Executive Law sections 292, 296 and 297 and Real Property Law sections 227-f and 238-a (nysenate.gov, read through the r.jina.ai text proxy); State Division of Human Rights and Attorney General pages; and the court documents in Commons West. General information, not legal advice.
Sources for this article (27)
- Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(a)(1) (nyc.gov)
- source of income page (nyc.gov)
- landlord FAQ (nyc.gov)
- amendments page (nyc.gov)
- Local Law 119 of 2020 (nyc.gov)
- source of income page (ag.ny.gov)
- Commons West decision (decisions.courts.state.ny.us)
- Executive Law 296(5)(a) and (c) (nysenate.gov)
- Executive Law 297(5) (nysenate.gov)
- chapter 5 (nyc.gov)
- reporting page (dhr.ny.gov)
- denied a stay motion "as unnecessary" (nycourts.gov)
- broker FAQ (nyc.gov)
- apartment hunting page (nyc.gov)
- tenant FAQ (nyc.gov)
- Section 8 page (dhr.ny.gov)
- notice to housing providers (dos.ny.gov)
- Real Property Law 238-a(1)(b) (nysenate.gov)
- Fair Chance Housing page (nyc.gov)
- Real Property Law 227-f (nysenate.gov)
- 2026 decisions and orders (nyc.gov)
- 2025 settlements (nyc.gov)
- Mayor's Office (nyc.gov)
- 2026 settlements (nyc.gov)
- Division release (dhr.ny.gov)
- press release (nyc.gov)
- Commission report form (nyc.gov)
Stay Updated on Housing
Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.
VoucherMatch Editorial Team
Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected
Find apartments
Listings on VoucherMatch come from landlords who say up front which vouchers they accept.
Related Articles
Section 8 Lead Paint Requirements NYC: Local Law 1 and HUD
Section 8 lead paint requirements in NYC: HUD inspection rules, Local Law 1 annual notices, XRF testing, HPD exemptions, the July 2027 deadline and penalties.
13 min readHow to Screen Section 8 Tenants in NYC: What the Law Allows
How to screen Section 8 tenants in NYC: what the agency checks, what landlords may check, and the legal limits on income, credit, court and criminal records.
12 min readHow to Become a Section 8 Landlord in NYC
There is no application to become a Section 8 landlord in NYC. NYCHA, HPD and HCR approve one tenancy at a time. The nine steps and the documents.
8 min readSection 8 in a NYC Co-op or Condo: Can the Board Refuse?
Section 8 in a NYC co-op or condo: the City law covers boards that approve rentals, the unit owner signs the HAP contract, and the unit must pass inspection.
12 min readCan a Landlord Charge Extra on Top of Section 8 Rent? Side Payments Explained
No. A landlord in the voucher program cannot demand or accept any rent from the tenant beyond the tenant's approved share, and must return any excess. Charging extra for things other tenants get as part of rent is also banned. A few separate charges are allowed, such as a security deposit and agreed extras that are not part of the lease. Here is the rule for tenants and landlords, and what to do if it happens.
8 min readSection 8 Rent Increase: How to Request One (60-Day Rule)
How to request a Section 8 rent increase: 60 days' notice to the housing agency, the reasonable rent test, who pays the difference, and five agencies compared.
10 min readList Your Property Today
Join hundreds of landlords connecting with qualified voucher holders on VoucherMatch.
Weighing a purchase? The RentalCalcs investment calculators from the VoucherMatch team run cash flow and Section 8 rent for any address, free.