Skip to page content

NYC Brokers Fined for Voucher Discrimination: The Record

Checked October 7, 20269 min readBy VoucherMatch Editorial Team
New York City Hall and its front steps
New York City Hall and its front steps (2007). Photo: LeoTar, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Quick answerIn New York City, official documents read on October 7, 2026 record 39 voucher discrimination actions from January 2022 to August 2026, 16 of them naming or describing a broker, brokerage or agent. Nearly all are settlements. Two are Commission on Human Rights decisions after trial, both dated August 3, 2026 and both against brokerages. The largest broker settlement is CitiHabitats at $270,000. The City's civil penalty ceiling is $125,000, or $250,000 for a willful act.
The published record in six numbers
  • 39actions in the documents read, January 2022 to August 2026 (VoucherMatch's count)
  • 16of those name or describe a broker, brokerage or agent
  • 2decisions after trial, both August 3, 2026, both against brokerages
  • $270,000CitiHabitats settlement, January to June 2025
  • $125,000 / $250,000City civil penalty ceilings, ordinary and willful
  • 1 yeardeadline to file with the City Commission

The Cases

The published record for brokers is 16 actions since 2022: 11 Commission settlements, one Commission pre-complaint intervention, two Commission decisions after trial, one Attorney General agreement and one State Division settlement. Each row names the respondent as the document does.

A settlement is an agreement. Unless a row says "decision," no agency ruled that the respondent broke the law, and nothing here should be read as an admission.

The glass entrance of an office tower with 28 LIBERTY lettered above the revolving doors and an empty stone plaza in front
The entrance to 28 Liberty Street in the Financial District, Manhattan, September 2020. The building is the address of the New York State Attorney General's New York City office. Photo: Epicgenius, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Actions naming or describing a broker, brokerage or agent, January 2022 to August 2026. Dates are the day or period the document gives. CCHR is the NYC Commission on Human Rights
DateRespondent as namedWhat the document saysMoney terms statedOther terms statedSource
Feb. 2022Absolute Properties of NYC LLC, a real estate agencyConciliation agreement. The complainant "alleged" an agent said the firm did not accept HRA broker's fee vouchers$6,000 damagesTraining, notices, revised policiesCCHR 2022
Nov. 1, 2022Compass Inc., a brokerageAgreement with the Attorney General, whose office "found" that agents refused to process applications from Section 8 holders in ManhattanNone statedFee waived for first 25 Section 8 applicants; 90% of commission to agents; trainingAttorney General
Jan. to June 2023MySpace NYC RealtySettlement. The respondent told a Section 8 holder there was a waitlist for voucher holders$4,000 damages, $3,000 penaltiesTraining; broker incentive program letting agents keep 90% of HRA's feeCCHR 2023
Jan. to June 2023Bond New York Properties Brokerage LLCSettlement "for refusing to accept HRA broker fees"$25,000 to each of two complainants, $30,000 penaltiesPolicy changes, training, broker incentive program, outreachCCHR 2023
2023, listed in both halvesBrothers Estates Inc. (landlord), First Service Residential (property manager), First Service Realty (broker)Settlement. Complainants "alleged" they were denied a Brooklyn apartment because of a Section 8 voucher$10,000 damagesRevised policies, trainingCCHR 2023
Jan. to June 2024A broker, not namedSettlement. A HASA voucher holder was unable to view an apartment. Commission testers asking about the same unit "received an immediate, positive response"$7,500 damages, $5,000 penaltiesTraining, broker incentive program, 2 years of monitoringCCHR 2024
July to Dec. 2024Douglas EllimanSettlement of a Commission-initiated complaint after Housing Rights Initiative testers "were informed that vouchers were not accepted or wouldn't work for the building"$35,000 penalties, $15,000 application fee fundBroker incentive program, more testing, trainingCCHR 2024
Jan. to June 2025CitiHabitats Real Estate AgencySettlement of four complaints. In each, a broker "falsely stated" that people with vouchers were not allowed to apply$270,000 in damages and penaltiesTraining, policy audit, public display of policiesCCHR 2025
Jan. to June 2025Compass Inc.Settlement of two cases. Two voucher holders "were not permitted to apply." A Housing Rights Initiative tester was told of income and credit minimums "despite the voucher covering 100% of the rent"$25,000 to each complainant, $110,000 penaltiesListing partnership with the City's Public Engagement Unit; trainingCCHR 2025
July to Dec. 2025Compass RealtySettlement. A broker refused to rent and emailed "Vouchers? NOT ACCEPTED Not accepted."$20,000 damages, $50,000 penaltiesTrainingCCHR 2025
2025, no day givenUrban Pads LLC, a Brooklyn brokerage, and affiliated agentsState Division settlement. The Fair Housing Justice Center "alleged" testers with vouchers were treated differently$40,000 to the CenterFree placement help for ten subsidy holders a year for three years; trainingState Division
Jan. to May 2026A landlord and a broker, not namedSettlement. The pair refused a domestic violence survivor, "claiming that they 'don't take section 8'"$15,000 damages, $10,000 penaltiesTraining, monitoringCCHR 2026
Jan. to May 2026Cityscape Living, a brokerage firmPre-complaint intervention after NYCHA reported application questions on criminal history and source of incomeNoneNew application, training, a policy for agentsCCHR 2026
Jan. to May 2026Bond NYSettlement. An agent "insisted that a credit score was also required"$10,000 damages, $30,000 application assistance fundTraining, policy revisions, posters, staff noticeCCHR 2026
Aug. 3, 2026New American Realty Corp. and an individual brokerDecision after trial. Respondents "were held liable" for source of income discrimination and for discrimination tied to pregnancy, marital status and the presence of children$101,816 damages, $45,000 penaltyTraining, notices, written policiesCCHR decisions
Aug. 3, 2026NY Pyramid Group Corp. and an individual brokerDecision after trial, held as an inquest because the respondents did not appear. "Held liable" for refusing a renter using City rental assistance$75,000 damages, $50,000 penaltyTraining, notices, written policiesCCHR decisions

What it means: the Commission's pages use the names Compass Inc., Compass Realty, Bond New York Properties Brokerage LLC and Bond NY, and do not say whether any two are the same company.

Source: the documents linked in each row, read October 7, 2026.

About the records
The Commission's settlement pages give a half-year or a month, not a day. Its 2025 heading prints the CitiHabitats figure as "$270,0000" and the text as $270,000. Its 2023 page lists the Brothers Estates matter twice and spells one respondent both "First Service Realty" and "FirstService Realty."

Landlords, managers and co-ops in the same documents

The same documents hold 23 more actions against landlords, managers, co-ops and respondents whose role the page does not state.

Other source of income actions in the documents read, January 2022 to August 2026. All are settlements. Each is on the Commission's page for its year unless a link says otherwise
DateRespondent as namedWhat the document saysTerms stated
Jan. 2022REM ResidentialComplainant "alleged" a refusal to fill out Section 8 paperwork$4,000 damages; 5 apartments set aside
Jan. 2022Advantage Management Property, Wavecrest Management, Northern Manhattan Equities LLC, Hurston Place Equities LLCDisability, source of income and retaliation case. "Respondents denied the allegations"$25,000 damages, $5,000 penalties, two-year rent credit
June 2022Bronstein Properties LLCA HASA client was told "landlord doesn't accept programs"$5,000; 20 apartments set aside
Jan. to June 2023A landlord, not namedTried to evict a 40-year tenant after refusing Section 8$30,000 damages, $12,000 penalties
Jan. to June 2023Benenson Funding CorporationComplainant was told respondents "do not take vouchers"$10,000; all vacancies set aside for 18 months
Jan. to June 2023Premier One Realty LLCSaid it had to confirm the landlord took Section 8 before the complainant could apply$4,000 damages, $4,000 penalties
Jan. to June 2023Lefrak CityRefused an HRA security deposit voucher$35,000 damages and attorney's fees, $15,000 penalties
Jan. to June 20232100 Beekman Realty LLCTold a Section 8 holder it wanted a tenant who was employed$2,650 damages, $3,000 penalties; unit leased at reduced rent
July to Dec. 2023A respondent, not namedRefused to show any unit to a HASA client, "claiming no units were available"$45,000 damages, $10,000 penalties; placement incentives
July to Dec. 2023Hamilton Gatling Estates and 1440 Ocean Parkway LLCA FHEPS holder was put on a waitlist. Commission testing showed the same$5,000 damages, $10,000 penalties; 20 apartments set aside
July to Dec. 2023Allbren Realty Management, a landlordRefused a subsidy and began a holdover case$7,500 rent credit; eviction case dropped
Jan. to June 2024160 Beach 117 Owners Corporation and two ownersAn applicant with a voucher alleged discrimination$3,500 penalties
Jan. to June 2024A landlord, not namedRefused a Section 8 holder, then did not cooperate with NYCHA$10,216 damages, $27,500 penalties
Jan. to June 2024A landlord, not namedRefused a domestic violence survivor with a voucher$5,000 damages, $27,500 penalties
Jan. to June 20241260 Broadway LLCNot described. The complainant held Section 8$5,000 damages, $27,500 penalties
July to Dec. 2024A landlord, not namedDid not make repairs needed for Section 8 payments$15,000 damages, $5,000 attorney's fees
July to Dec. 2024A co-op board, not namedDenied a voucher holder a shareholder had agreed to rent to$5,000 damages, $5,000 lost income
Aug. 20, 2024Shamco Management Corp.Attorney General settlement. The office "found" refusals, ignored applicants and inflated rents$400,000 restitution; 65 units
Aug. 22, 2024Parkchester Preservation ManagementSettlement announced by the Mayor over minimum income rules and non-refundable deposits$1 million penalties; 850 apartments set aside
Jan. to June 2025A landlord, not namedRefused an Emergency Housing Voucher$10,000 damages; 10 units set aside
Jan. to May 2026A landlord, not namedRefused an emergency housing voucher$10,000 damages; 2 units set aside
Jan. to May 2026Surrey Co-Operative ApartmentsPurchase complaint "alleging" race and source of income discriminationNo money; training, revised policies
Jan. to May 2026A landlord, not namedWould not fill out paperwork for a sitting tenant$35,000 damages, $5,000 penalties; all vacancies set aside for 2 years

What it means: set-aside apartments appear in landlord settlements, while broker settlements more often carry incentive programs and application funds. Co-op cases from 2021 are in the co-op and condo article.

Source: Commission on Human Rights settlement pages for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026, and the two linked releases.

VoucherMatch's count of the documents read

The count below is VoucherMatch's own tally of the two tables above. It is not the agencies' full record: the Commission calls its pages "Settlement Highlights."

VoucherMatch count: source of income actions in the documents read, by year
All actionsActions naming or describing a broker, brokerage or agent
View the data table
YearAll actionsActions naming or describing a broker, brokerage or agent
202252
2023113
2024102
202554
2026, to August85

What it means: brokers are a larger share of the published actions in 2025 and 2026 than before, though the pages are a selection and 2026 is a partial year.

Source: VoucherMatch's count of the 39 actions listed above.

VoucherMatch sum: money terms stated in those documents, by year, dollars
View the data table
YearStated money terms
2022$45,000
2023$290,150
2024$1,598,716
2025$550,000
2026, to August$386,816

What it means: the total is $2,870,682, and two 2024 landlord settlements, Parkchester and Shamco, are $1.4 million of it.

Source: VoucherMatch's sum of every dollar figure in the two tables: damages, penalties, restitution, attorney's fees, funds and the one rent credit with a stated value.

VoucherMatch count by type of respondent, as each document describes it
Type of respondentActionsStated money terms
Brokerage, broker or agent14$1,007,316
Landlord and broker together2$35,000
Landlord or manager17$1,712,866
Co-op2$10,000
Role not stated on the page4$105,500

What it means: set-aside units, fee waivers and unvalued rent credits are not in the dollar column, so the figures understate what respondents agreed to.

Source: VoucherMatch's count.

Six Things That Got Agents in Trouble

The six kinds of conduct below are the ones the documents describe, each matched to the Commission's broker FAQ.

Conduct described in the documents, and the Commission's guidance on it
  • 1. Saying vouchers are not takenCitiHabitats, Compass Realty, Douglas Elliman and the 2026 landlord-and-broker matter all involve a statement that vouchers were not accepted. Premier One Realty said it had to ask the landlord first. FAQ answer 2: "You should not work with owners who discriminate."
  • 2. Income and credit minimumsCompass Inc. (2025) and Bond NY (2026). FAQ answer 5: a required income is "unnecessary and a discriminatory practice," and "if the voucher/subsidy covers 100% of the rent, you are prohibited from considering credit."
  • 3. Refusing a program or its feeBond New York Properties Brokerage (2023) and Absolute Properties (2022) concern HRA broker fees. FAQ answer 8: accepting only some programs is a violation "even if certain programs require extra paperwork, pay a lower fee to the broker, or involve longer processing times."
  • 4. Waitlists and separate listsMySpace NYC Realty and Hamilton Gatling Estates. FAQ answer 3: "Maintaining separate lists of apartments for voucher/subsidy recipients is a discriminatory practice."
  • 5. Slow or no responsein the 2024 HASA matter, testers got "an immediate, positive response" on a unit the complainant could not view. The State Division's Urban Pads release calls going quiet "ghosting."
  • 6. Application questions and upfront chargesCityscape Living's application asked about source of income. Parkchester involved "non-refundable deposits." FAQ answer 7 puts the application fee at $20 or the actual cost of the check, whichever is less, with nothing more until the agency approves the move.

What it means: none of these six needs the word "no." How to screen Section 8 tenants covers the screening the law still allows.

Source: the documents in the tables above and the Commission's broker FAQ (file dated January 2020).

Testers Are Real

Testing is in the documents themselves: five of the 16 broker actions mention testers.

  • Housing Rights Initiative: Douglas Elliman (2024) and Compass Inc. (2025)
  • Commission testers: the unnamed broker (2024) and NY Pyramid Group Corp. (2026)
  • Fair Housing Justice Center: Urban Pads LLC (2025)

The Commission says it uses "matched pair, in-person, telephone, and online testing" (source of income page). It can also open a case with no tenant complaint: under Administrative Code section 8-109(c) it "may itself make, sign and file a verified complaint."

What's at Stake for a Brokerage

A brokerage faces a City civil penalty of up to $125,000, or $250,000 for a willful act, plus uncapped damages and a possible licence case at the State.

Penalty framework for source of income discrimination by a licensee in New York City, as read October 7, 2026
LawWhat it allowsWho receives it
Administrative Code 8-126(a)Civil penalty "of not more than $125,000"; "not more than $250,000" for a "willful, wanton or malicious act"The City's general fund (8-127)
Administrative Code 8-120(a)Compensatory damages, an order to rent, compliance reports, attorney's feesThe complainant
Administrative Code 8-124Up to $50,000, plus up to $100 a day, for failing to comply with a conciliation order or a decision and orderThe City
Executive Law 297(4)(c)Fines up to $50,000, or $100,000 if "willful, wanton or malicious"; compensatory damages; punitive damages up to $10,000 in housing casesThe State (fines); the complainant (damages)
Real Property Law 441-cLicence revocation or suspension, "a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars," or a reprimand, for a Human Rights Law violation committed as a licenseeDepartment of State
19 NYCRR 175.17(b)An agency or court finding of discrimination in licensed activity is "presumptive evidence of untrustworthiness"Department of State

What it means: the largest broker civil penalty stated on its own in the documents read, $110,000 for Compass Inc., is under the ordinary ceiling.

Source: Administrative Code Title 8, chapter 1; Executive Law 297, read through a text proxy; Department of State Real Estate License Law booklet, March 2026.

The broker FAQ says a licensee is "responsible for the actions of anyone who works under your broker's license." Section 8-107(13)(d) of the Administrative Code lets an employer plead its anti-discrimination policies and its record when liability rests solely on the conduct of an employee, agent or independent contractor.

No Department of State decision disciplining a licensee for source of income discrimination was found on dos.ny.gov on October 7, 2026. The Commission's FAQ says it "may report a licensed agent" to the Division of Licensing Services.

Watch outThe City says the State ruling does not apply to its own law.On March 5, 2026 a State appeals court affirmed judgments declaring the State provision "facially unconstitutional to the extent that" it bars refusing tenants "because their source of income includes Section 8 vouchers." The appeal is pending. The City Commission's chair said on May 4, 2026 that the ruling "doesn't apply to the New York City law directly." Every Commission action above is under the City law. The Commons West article follows the case.

How a Complaint Proceeds at the Commission

A complaint moves from filing to investigation, then to a settlement or a trial before an administrative law judge, and most published outcomes are settlements.

A source of income complaint under Administrative Code Title 8
  1. 1Filing (8-109)a person files a verified complaint within one year of the act, or the Commission files its own
  2. 2Investigation (8-114)the Commission can subpoena records and order them preserved
  3. 3Mediation and conciliation (8-115)possible "at any time after the filing." A conciliation agreement becomes an order and is public unless the parties and the Commission agree otherwise
  4. 4Probable cause (8-116)if found, or if the Commission filed the case itself, the complaint goes to an administrative law judge
  5. 5Hearing (8-119)testimony under oath. If the respondent has not answered, the judge may enter a default
  6. 6Decision and order (8-120, 8-126)the Commission states findings and may order damages, penalties and other relief
  7. 7Court review (8-123)a petition to State Supreme Court within 30 days of service

What it means: the NY Pyramid complaint was first filed in January 2021, tried in April 2024 and decided in August 2026.

Source: Administrative Code sections 8-109 to 8-126 and the Commission's complaint process page, updated April 24, 2026.

In that case the judge recommended $10,000 in damages and a $20,000 penalty. The Commission's final order set $75,000 and $50,000. Tenants deciding where to file can use how to report voucher discrimination in NYC.

A granite courthouse with a wide flight of steps and a colonnade of ten columns under a carved pediment, seen from the street
The New York State Supreme Court building at 60 Centre Street in Manhattan, May 2026. Photo: Ajay Suresh, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

What to Do When an Owner Refuses

The Commission's FAQ tells a broker to stop working with the owner, keep a log, tell the Commission and give the applicant a denial letter.

Broker FAQ answers 2, 4 and 6: when an owner rejects a voucher applicant
  • Log. the owner's name, the unit address, the reason given, notes and correspondence, and a copy of the denied application
  • Report. notify the Commission. The FAQ prints an older number; the Commission's current page gives 212-416-0197
  • Denial letter. the action taken, the address, the explanation, and how to complain to the Commission
  • Claimed exemption. put the reason in a letter and say it applies only to that listing
  • The owner. "You should not work with owners who discriminate"

What it means: answer 4 of that FAQ still describes a six-unit threshold that was repealed in 2021. Can a landlord refuse Section 8 in NYC sets out the two exemptions in force.

Source: Commission on Human Rights, Best Practices for Licensed Salespersons and Brokers.

What Agency Guidance Asks of a Brokerage

Agency guidance asks for equal handling of every program, written State notices, and training.

Compliance items found in agency guidance and regulations
  • Screening and listings. the six items above, from broker FAQ answers 2, 3, 5, 7 and 8
  • Credit decisions. where the tenant pays a share, case by case, with a written explanation to the applicant (answer 5)
  • State notice. give the fair housing disclosure at first substantive contact, not orally, and keep it three years (19 NYCRR 175.28)
  • Posting. the State notice at every office, on each website's home page and at open houses (19 NYCRR 175.29)
  • Training. the Commission lists a 1.5-credit continuing education course, "The City Human Rights Law and Discrimination in Housing"

The forms and fee steps for voucher deals are in how to become a CityFHEPS broker, how brokers get paid on voucher deals and the FARE Act article.

Frequently Asked Questions

Am I liable if the landlord told me to turn away voucher holders?

The City law applies to brokers and salespeople in their own right (section 8-107(5)(c)). The Commission's FAQ tells brokers not to work with owners who discriminate. In the 2026 "don't take section 8" settlement, the landlord and the broker both agreed to pay.

Can I ask a voucher holder for a credit score?

Not if the voucher covers 100% of the rent, according to the Commission's FAQ. If the tenant pays a share, credit may be considered case by case, and a required score "may trigger an investigation."

Can I tell a client a building "only takes Section 8, not CityFHEPS"?

No, according to FAQ answer 8: "Accepting only some vouchers or programs still violates the NYC Human Rights Law."

Are these settlements public?

Yes. Section 8-115(d) makes every conciliation agreement public unless the parties agree otherwise and the Commission decides disclosure is not required.

Does the Commission only act on complaints?

No. It files its own complaints (section 8-109(c)), uses testers, and acted before any complaint in the Cityscape Living matter after a notice from NYCHA.

How much is the fine for voucher discrimination in NYC?

Up to $125,000, or $250,000 for a willful, wanton or malicious act, under section 8-126(a), plus damages.

Sources

How this article was checked

Last checked: October 7, 2026, against the NYC Commission on Human Rights settlement pages for 2022 to 2026 and its 2026 decisions page, with the two August 3, 2026 decisions; the Mayor's Office release of August 22, 2024; Attorney General releases of November 1, 2022 and August 20, 2024; the State Division of Human Rights settlement release and list; Administrative Code Title 8; Executive Law 297; and the Department of State's Real Estate License Law booklet (March 2026). General information, not legal advice.

Sources for this article (20)
  1. CCHR 2022 (nyc.gov)
  2. Attorney General (ag.ny.gov)
  3. CCHR 2023 (nyc.gov)
  4. CCHR 2024 (nyc.gov)
  5. CCHR 2025 (nyc.gov)
  6. State Division (dhr.ny.gov)
  7. CCHR 2026 (nyc.gov)
  8. CCHR decisions (nyc.gov)
  9. Attorney General settlement (ag.ny.gov)
  10. Settlement announced by the Mayor (nyc.gov)
  11. broker FAQ (nyc.gov)
  12. source of income page (nyc.gov)
  13. Administrative Code section 8-109(c) (nyc.gov)
  14. Executive Law 297 (nysenate.gov)
  15. Real Estate License Law booklet, March 2026 (dos.ny.gov)
  16. affirmed judgments (decisions.courts.state.ny.us)
  17. said on May 4, 2026 (nyc.gov)
  18. complaint process page (nyc.gov)
  19. Miller v. New American Realty Corp. (nyc.gov)
  20. Morgan v. NY Pyramid Group Corp. (nyc.gov)
Share:

Stay Updated on Housing

Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.

VoucherMatch Editorial Team

Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected

Related Articles

Guides

How Brokers Get Paid on NYC Voucher Deals: HRA-121, DSS-8f

How brokers get paid on NYC voucher deals: HRA-121, DSS-8f, W-147JJ and NYCHA's form, who signs each, what to attach, where it goes and the 30-day deadlines.

9 min read
For Tenants

How to Report a Landlord Who Refuses Your Voucher in NYC

Refusing a housing voucher is illegal in NYC. Who to call, the one-year City deadline and three-year State deadline, and what evidence to keep.

7 min read
Guides

How to Pitch a Landlord on a Voucher Tenant: A Script for Caseworkers

A talk track for housing caseworkers and navigators calling landlords about a Section 8 or other voucher client. What to say first, how the money and inspection actually work, which housing authorities pay landlord incentives, and honest answers to the objections you will hear.

9 min read
Guides

Housing Search Log Template for Voucher Holders and Caseworkers

An editable Excel housing search log and a copy-paste version for voucher holders and caseworkers. Track contacts, application outcomes and follow-ups, check your housing authority's documentation rules, and share only the information needed.

7 min read
Guides

SHARE Voucher NYC: What It Is and How Landlords Get Paid

The SHARE voucher in NYC is a State funded rent subsidy for long-term shelter residents, run by Anthos|Home. Who qualifies, how long it lasts, who pays rent.

10 min read
Guides

Section 8 Voucher Extension Request Letter: 3 Samples

Section 8 voucher extension request letter samples, the federal rule in 24 CFR 982.303, and what six housing agencies allow, require and set as a deadline.

9 min read

Explore the NYC broker workspace

Keep your client’s housing search moving with practical guides and the right workspace.