Skip to page content

What to Do When Your Section 8 Tenant Doesn't Pay Their Portion

Checked October 5, 202610 min readBy VoucherMatch Editorial Team
A row of two-story yellow-brick row houses with stoops, awnings and metal cornices, with cars parked along the curb and bare street trees.
Row houses on De Kalb Avenue in Bushwick, Brooklyn, November 2012. Photo: Jim.henderson, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Quick answerIn New York City, as of October 2026, an unpaid tenant share is rent the tenant owes you, and the housing agency will not cover it. Confirm the amount on the agency's latest notice, ask whether the tenant's income fell, and tell the agency. If it stays unpaid, state law requires a certified-mail late notice and a 14-day rent demand before a Housing Court case, and NYCHA requires its eviction certification first. Only a court can evict.
The numbers at a glance
  • $0how much of the agency's share you may collect from the tenant
  • 5 daysrent overdue before a certified-mail late notice is required
  • 14 daysminimum written rent demand before a nonpayment case
  • $50 or 5%the late fee cap, whichever is less
  • Form 059.518NYCHA's certification, filed before you start a case
  • 30 to 45 daysHRA's stated wait for a One-Shot Deal rent decision

Understanding the Payment Structure

The rent is split into the agency's housing assistance payment (HAP) and the tenant's share, and you can only ever collect the tenant's share from the tenant.

Who owes what
  • The tenantowes you the part of the rent the HAP does not cover. Not paying it is a serious lease violation, and it is yours to enforce under the lease.
  • The agency (NYCHA, HPD or NYS HCR)owes you only the HAP. The contract says it "shall not pay any other claim by the owner against the family."
  • Youmay not demand or accept more from the tenant than the rent minus the HAP, and may not end the tenancy because the agency paid late or not at all.

What it means: a late or abated HAP is a matter between you and the agency, never a balance on the tenant's ledger.

Source: 24 CFR 982.310; 24 CFR 982.451; 24 CFR 982.515; form HUD-52641, Part B section 7.e; form HUD-52641-A, section 5.

ExampleThese figures are made up. The rent is $2,400, the HAP is $1,800 and the tenant's share is $600. The tenant misses two months. The arrears are $1,200, not $4,800, even if the HAP was also late.

How each agency sets and pays the two amounts is in how landlords get paid with Section 8.

The upper floors of a red-brick corner apartment house with a red mansard roof, dormer windows, window air conditioners and a green fire escape.
Apartment house at the corner of Meserole Street and Graham Avenue in Brooklyn, September 2008. Photo: Jim.henderson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

What You Can and Cannot Collect From the Tenant

You can collect the unpaid tenant share and a capped late fee, and nothing that belongs to the agency.

ItemCan you bill the tenant?Can you seek it in a nonpayment case?
Unpaid tenant shareYesYes
The agency's HAP, late, abated or stoppedNoNo
Late feeOnly once rent is more than five days late, up to $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is lessNo. Only rent may be sought in the case
Meals, supportive services or furniture you provideNot as a required chargeNo. Nonpayment is not grounds to end the tenancy
Anything above the rent the agency approvedNo. Return any excess at onceNo

What it means: keep rent, late fees and other charges in separate ledger columns, because only the rent column goes into a rent demand or petition.

Source: 24 CFR 982.451; form HUD-52641-A, sections 5 and 6; Real Property Law 238-a; RPAPL 702.

The late fee law does not say whether "monthly rent" means the tenant's share or the full rent in a voucher tenancy, and no agency or court guidance on the point was found. Measuring it on the tenant's share is the cautious reading.

Step 1: Document Everything

Start with a ledger that shows the tenant's share by month, because every later notice has to state the months and amounts owed.

What to pull together first
  • The agency's latest notice of the tenant's share. HPD calls it a rent breakdown letter. Bill that figure and no other.
  • A month-by-month ledger. the share due, what was paid, and the date, with HAP payments in a separate column.
  • The lease, the HAP contract and the tenancy addendum. the addendum controls where it and the lease differ.
  • Rent receipts. New York requires a written receipt for rent paid in cash or by any method other than the tenant's personal check.
  • Every letter, text and email about the missed rent..

What it means: if the ledger mixes the HAP into the tenant's balance, fix it before you send anything.

Source: form HUD-52641; NY Attorney General, Residential Tenants' Rights Guide.

Step 2: Communicate with Your Tenant

Ask what happened before you send a formal notice, because the most common causes have a fix that gets you paid.

  • Income fell: the tenant can ask the agency for an interim recertification, which lowers the share and raises the HAP.
  • The amount is disputed: compare your ledger with the agency's notice. The agency must tell both of you when the share changes.
  • A one-time setback: the city's One-Shot Deal can pay rent arrears straight to you.
Watch outSkipping the certified-mail late notice gives the tenant a defense.One written notice is not optional. When rent is more than five days late, state law requires you to send a notice by certified mail saying the rent was not received. If you skip it, the tenant can raise that as a defense in a nonpayment case (Real Property Law 235-e).
A two-story red-brick post office with a slate roof, an American flag over the entrance, two blue mailboxes on the sidewalk and cars parked in front.
The Flatbush Station post office at 2273 Church Avenue in Flatbush, Brooklyn, August 2013. Photo: Beyond My Ken, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Ways to Clear the Arrears Without a Court Case

Four routes can clear the balance or lower the share, and the tenant has to start three of them.

What can get the rent paid
  • Interim recertificationthe tenant reports the income drop to the agency. HPD backdates a cut to the first of the month after the report when proof arrives within 90 days. Steps for all three agencies are in reporting an income change.
  • Minimum rent hardship (NYCHA)a household at NYCHA's $50 minimum rent can get an exception if it would be evicted because it cannot pay it, or if income fell through job loss.
  • One-Shot DealHRA accepts a rent demand or a landlord's letter showing the monthly breakdown and the amount owed, needs no court case, and issues the check to the landlord or to Housing Court. See how to apply for a One-Shot Deal.
  • A written payment planstate the agreed balance, the dates and the amounts, and keep new monthly rent separate from the arrears.

What it means: an interim cut lowers future rent but not months already owed, so a tenant with real arrears usually needs the One-Shot Deal as well.

Source: HPD Administrative Plan, section 13.3.2; NYCHA Administrative Plan, chapter IX.A; HRA One-Shot Deal flyer.

HRA says a rent decision can take 30 to 45 days once every document is in. Giving the tenant an accurate rent breakdown letter the day they ask is the part you control.

Step 3: Report the Problem to the Housing Authority

Tell the agency that holds the voucher, in writing with your ledger, because each one can act on the tenant's file and one of them requires a form before any court case.

Who to tell and what each agency says it does, as of October 5, 2026
AgencyContactWhat it says it doesWhat it requires from you
NYCHA718-707-7771, weekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., or the Owner Extranet"May terminate the tenant's participation in the Section 8 program"Form 059.518 before a nonpayment case
HPD917-286-4300Reviews your documentation and, "if necessary," warns the tenant. With sufficient proof of nonpayment it will consider ending assistance, with no court order neededA copy of any eviction notice
NYS HCRSubsidy Services Bureau, 212-480-6672Treats nonpayment of rent as a serious lease violationA copy of any eviction notice; word when a case starts; the judgment; eviction papers within 5 business days

What it means: a report puts the problem on record with the agency, but no agency collects the tenant's share for you.

Source: NYCHA Property Owner Guide; HPD Section 8 rights and responsibilities; HPD Administrative Plan, section 15.8; HCR Administrative Plan, sections 12-I.D, 12-III.C and 12-III.D; HCR Subsidy Services Bureau.

Not sure which agency holds the voucher? Check before you do anything else, using HPD vs NYCHA Section 8.

Step 4: The Certification of Basis for Eviction

For a NYCHA voucher, you must send NYCHA Form 059.518, the Certification of Basis for Eviction, before you start a nonpayment case. HPD and HCR publish no such form.

NYCHA's certification, in order
  1. 1Get the formlog in to the Owner Extranet, where NYCHA says you can obtain or submit the eviction certification.
  2. 2Mail it to the tenantNYCHA wants the form submitted "along with proof you also mailed this form to the tenant."
  3. 3Submit it to NYCHAdo this before the court case starts. NYCHA publishes no response time.
  4. 4If NYCHA objectsyou may still go to Housing Court, but you must name NYCHA as a co-defendant in the same case.

What it means: the certification is a condition of the case, not a courtesy. The same form is required before a holdover that follows a terminated or suspended subsidy.

Source: NYCHA Property Owner Guide.

Watch outSkipping the NYCHA certification can undo an eviction.In a 2017 New York City landlord-tenant decision, an owner who thought the voucher was HPD's skipped the NYCHA certification, won by default and evicted. The court dismissed the case and restored the tenant to possession.

The rule comes from a 1995 federal consent judgment, Williams v. NYCHA. The form is behind the Extranet login and could not be read, so what it asks and how NYCHA must be served with court papers are not listed here. Confirm both with NYCHA or your lawyer.

HPD and HCR vouchers: the federal tenancy addendum requires you to give the agency a copy of any eviction notice, including the petition, at the same time you give it to the tenant (form HUD-52641-A, section 11). That rule covers NYCHA vouchers too.

Step 5: Nonpayment Proceeding in Housing Court

A nonpayment case can start only after the two state notices, and for NYCHA the certification, and it can ask only for the tenant's share. This section is general information, not legal advice.

From a missed payment to a court date in New York City
  • Rent due datethe date in the lease. A payment is late only after five more days.
  • More than 5 days latesend the certified-mail notice. A late fee, within the cap, is allowed from here.
  • At least 14 days before filingserve a written rent demand that lists the months and amounts and demands payment or possession. It must include the state's Good Cause Eviction Law notice.
  • Before filing, NYCHA onlysubmit Form 059.518.
  • Filingfile the petition in Housing Court in the county where the building is, and give the agency a copy.
  • Before the hearingif the tenant pays the full rent due, you must accept it and the case is over.
  • First court datethe case goes to a Resolution Part. The court says the vast majority of nonpayment cases settle in conferences.
  • After a judgmenta marshal carries out the warrant. If the tenant pays the full rent before then, the court must cancel the warrant unless you prove the rent was withheld in bad faith.

What it means: at every stage, payment in full ends the case, which is the result you wanted.

Source: NYC Housing Court, Starting a Nonpayment Case and Judgments in Nonpayment Cases; RPAPL 711, 731 and 749; Real Property Law 235-e.

  • Ask only for the tenant's share. An appellate court held it was error to award more than the tenant's share in a nonpayment case (Rippy v Kyer, 2009). For NYCHA vouchers, a New York City judge wrote that "strict compliance" with the consent judgment is required and cases are dismissed when its steps are skipped (2018 decision).
  • The HAP keeps coming. The agency must pay its share while the family lives in the unit, at least until a court allows the eviction. NYCHA and HPD pay until the household is evicted or moves out (24 CFR 982.311).
  • Expect the tenant to have a lawyer. Tenants in nonpayment cases get a free lawyer if household income is under the court's limit, for example $29,160 for one person or $60,000 for four. The city says the service covers every ZIP code, regardless of immigration status (NYC Housing Court; HRA).

What happens after filing is covered in the Section 8 eviction process guide.

What About When There's No Current Lease?

An expired lease does not stop you from bringing a nonpayment case. The Housing Court's petition rules say the agreement "could be a lease or a month to month tenancy."

  • To collect rent: the sequence above is the same, including the notices and, for NYCHA, the certification.
  • To end the tenancy instead: that is a holdover case with its own notices. NYCHA requires Form 059.518 for a holdover that follows a terminated or suspended subsidy, and every agency must get a copy of a notice to vacate.
  • Rent-stabilized units: NYCHA's and HPD's plans say you must offer a renewal lease, and that accepting the voucher is a term of it.

Source: NYC Housing Court, Starting a Nonpayment Case; NYCHA Property Owner Guide; NYCHA Administrative Plan, chapter XIV.K; HPD Administrative Plan, section 15.9.

The Tenant's Voucher Can Be Terminated

The agency may end assistance for serious or repeated lease violations, and must end it if the family is evicted for one.

SituationWhat the rule saysSource
Tenant does not pay the shareThe agency may terminate assistance. HPD and HCR both name nonpayment of rent as a serious lease violation24 CFR 982.552, paragraph (c)(1); HPD plan 15.8; HCR plan 12-I.D
Family is evicted for a serious lease violationThe agency must terminate assistance24 CFR 982.552, paragraph (b)(2)
Agency terminates assistanceThe HAP stops, and the HAP contract and the lease end automaticallyform HUD-52641-A, sections 12 and 13

What it means: termination is the agency's decision after its own notice and hearing process, described in how to appeal a Section 8 termination, and it does not pay your arrears.

Source: the documents linked in the table.

Key pointDo not assume a tenant whose assistance ends then owes you the full contract rent. The appellate court in Rippy v Kyer reasoned that a Section 8 tenant agreed in the lease to pay only the tenant's share. Get legal advice before you bill more.

Prevention Strategies

Most arrears start with a share that changed or an income drop nobody reported, so watch the agency's notices.

  • Bill from the latest notice. The share can change at an annual or interim recertification.
  • Send the five-day notice every time. It is required, and it starts the conversation early.
  • Know the recertification date. NYCHA notifies tenants 150 days before theirs is due.
  • Ask about income changes. A tenant who reports a drop quickly gets a lower share sooner.

Resources

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a landlord evict a Section 8 tenant for not paying their portion of the rent? Yes, through a court case only. Nonpayment of rent due under the lease is a serious lease violation. New York requires a certified-mail late notice and a 14-day rent demand first, and NYCHA requires Form 059.518.

Can I sue a Section 8 tenant for the Housing Authority's share of the rent? No. The tenant is never responsible for the HAP, and you may not end the tenancy because the agency did not pay. Take a missing HAP up with the agency.

Who do I report Section 8 tenant nonpayment to? The agency that holds the voucher, with your ledger.

  • NYCHA: 718-707-7771 or the Owner Extranet
  • HPD: 917-286-4300
  • NYS HCR: 212-480-6672

What form do I have to file with NYCHA before starting an eviction case? NYCHA Form 059.518, the Certification of Basis for Eviction, submitted on the Owner Extranet with proof you mailed it to the tenant. NYCHA does not publish how long it takes to respond.

Does the agency keep paying its share during a nonpayment case? Yes. Federal rules require the HAP to continue while the family lives in the unit, at least until a court allows the eviction.

Can I charge a Section 8 tenant a late fee? Yes, within the state's limits.

  • When: only after rent is more than five days late
  • How much: $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is less
  • In court: the fee cannot be sought in a nonpayment case

Will a tenant lose their Section 8 voucher for not paying rent? They can. The agency may end assistance for serious or repeated lease violations and must end it after an eviction for one. The tenant gets notice and a hearing first.

Have a vacancy coming up? List your property on VoucherMatch to reach voucher holders who are searching now, or see what other owners are offering in the current listings.

How this article was checked

Last checked: October 5, 2026, against 24 CFR 982.310, 982.311, 982.451, 982.515, 982.551 and 982.552; HUD's HAP contract and tenancy addendum (forms HUD-52641 and HUD-52641-A, 4/2023); NYCHA's Property Owner Guide and May 2026 Administrative Plan; HPD's April 2025 Housing Choice Voucher Administrative Plan and rights and responsibilities page; NYS HCR's October 2026 Administrative Plan; the NYC Housing Court's nonpayment and free-lawyer pages; Real Property Law 235-e and 238-a; RPAPL 702, 711, 731 and 749; and HRA's One-Shot Deal flyer.

Sources for this article (30)
  1. 24 CFR 982.310 (ecfr.gov)
  2. 24 CFR 982.451 (ecfr.gov)
  3. 24 CFR 982.515 (ecfr.gov)
  4. form HUD-52641 (hud.gov)
  5. form HUD-52641-A (hud.gov)
  6. Real Property Law 238-a (newyork.public.law)
  7. RPAPL 702 (newyork.public.law)
  8. NY Attorney General, Residential Tenants' Rights Guide (ag.ny.gov)
  9. Real Property Law 235-e (newyork.public.law)
  10. HPD Administrative Plan (nyc.gov)
  11. NYCHA Administrative Plan (nyc.gov)
  12. HRA One-Shot Deal flyer (nyc.gov)
  13. Owner Extranet (eapps.nycha.info)
  14. NYCHA Property Owner Guide (nyc.gov)
  15. HPD Section 8 rights and responsibilities (nyc.gov)
  16. HCR Administrative Plan (hcr.ny.gov)
  17. HCR Subsidy Services Bureau (hcr.ny.gov)
  18. 2017 New York City landlord-tenant decision (nycourts.gov)
  19. NYC Housing Court, Starting a Nonpayment Case (nycourts.gov)
  20. Judgments in Nonpayment Cases (nycourts.gov)
  21. RPAPL 711 (newyork.public.law)
  22. 731 (newyork.public.law)
  23. 749 (newyork.public.law)
  24. Rippy v Kyer, 2009 (nycourts.gov)
  25. 2018 decision (nycourts.gov)
  26. 24 CFR 982.311 (ecfr.gov)
  27. NYC Housing Court (nycourts.gov)
  28. HRA (nyc.gov)
  29. 24 CFR 982.552 (ecfr.gov)
  30. NYC Housing Court: nonpayment proceedings (nycourts.gov)
Share:

Stay Updated on Housing

Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.

VoucherMatch Editorial Team

Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected

Find apartments

Listings on VoucherMatch come from landlords who say up front which vouchers they accept.

Related Articles

For Tenants

Section 8 for Mixed-Status Families: Who Qualifies, How the Subsidy Is Prorated, the "Elect Not to Contend" Rule, and Where HUD's 2026 Proposal Stands

A household where some members have eligible immigration status and others do not can receive Section 8 or public housing today, with the assistance reduced in proportion, and without the members who lack status having to disclose it. Here is the federal rule as written, the proration math with a worked example, the protection for members who do not claim status, and the exact status of HUD's February 2026 proposal to end prorated assistance.

12 min read
Guides

How Much Does Section 8 Pay in Oxnard? (FY2027 Payment Standards by ZIP)

Oxnard Section 8 ceilings are set ZIP by ZIP: FY2027 2-bedroom figures in Ventura County run from $1,980 to $3,330. The full spread by bedroom, your share of the rent, and who to call.

7 min read
Guides

How Much Does Section 8 Pay in Stockton? (FY2027 Payment Standards by ZIP)

Stockton Section 8 ceilings are set ZIP by ZIP: FY2027 2-bedroom figures in San Joaquin County run from $1,180 to $2,810. The full spread by bedroom, your share of the rent, and who to call.

6 min read
Guides

How Much Does Section 8 Pay in Bakersfield? (FY2027 Payment Standards by ZIP)

Bakersfield Section 8 ceilings are set ZIP by ZIP: FY2027 2-bedroom figures in Kern County run from $1,340 to $2,480. The full spread by bedroom, your share of the rent, and who to call.

6 min read
Guides

Fresno Section 8 Rent: Payment Standards and Utilities

Fresno Housing uses one countywide payment-standard schedule. See its adopted amounts, bedroom rule, utility comparison and application stages.

6 min read
Guides

How Much Does Section 8 Pay in San Jose? (SCCHA Standards and Household Costs)

Find SCCHA’s adopted rent lookup, utility allowance dates and household-cost questions for San Jose, plus the city and county program relationship.

5 min read

List Your Property Today

Join hundreds of landlords connecting with qualified voucher holders on VoucherMatch.

Weighing a purchase? The RentalCalcs investment calculators from the VoucherMatch team run cash flow and Section 8 rent for any address, free.