Commons West Ruling: Does It Apply to NYC Section 8?

Quick answerOn March 5, 2026, the Appellate Division, Third Department, affirmed judgments declaring New York State's source-of-income provision, Executive Law 296(5)(a)(1), "facially unconstitutional to the extent that" it bars refusing tenants "because their source of income includes Section 8 vouchers." The opinion does not mention New York City's Human Rights Law. The Attorney General appealed. On May 21, 2026 the Court of Appeals denied a stay "as unnecessary." No Court of Appeals decision was found as of October 7, 2026.
- March 5, 2026date the Third Department decided People v Commons West
- 5 justiceson the panel, with no dissent
- Fourth Amendmentthe constitutional provision the court relied on
- April 1, 2026date the Attorney General's office says it filed its notice of appeal
- May 21, 2026date the Court of Appeals denied a stay "as unnecessary"
- APL-2026-00035the Court of Appeals number shown on briefs filed in the appeal
Does this apply to NYC?
The opinion does not mention New York City's law, and the head of the City agency that enforces that law said on May 4, 2026 that the ruling "doesn't apply to the New York City law directly."
- The opinion itselfthe statute it rules on is Executive Law 296(5)(a)(1), part of the State Human Rights Law. The case arose from rentals "in the City of Ithaca, Tompkins County." VoucherMatch searched the full text and found no reference to the City's Administrative Code or to the New York City Human Rights Law.
- NYC Commission on Human Rights, May 4, 2026Commissioner Christine Clarke, on WNYC: "That ruling wasn't in New York City. It doesn't apply to the New York City law directly. It's being appealed."
- Other vouchers, same statement"a lot of those arguments don't apply to any of the other vouchers that are at issue. Certainly not to HASA or CityFHEPS or FHEPS or LINC or anything else. I feel very confident in our continued enforcement of that law."
- Attorney Generalno statement about the City law was found. The March 5, 2026 statement speaks only of "today's decision."
- Courtsno decision applying Commons West to Administrative Code 8-107(5) was found as of October 7, 2026. That is a search of public pages, not of court dockets.
What it means: the City rule sits in a different statute, Administrative Code 8-107(5), which can a landlord refuse Section 8 in NYC sets out section by section.
Source: Third Department opinion, March 5, 2026; Commission on Human Rights, transcript of the Brian Lehrer Show, May 4, 2026; Attorney General, statement of March 5, 2026.
Key pointThe Commission has kept issuing voucher decisions under the City law since the ruling. On August 4, 2026 it announced four final rulings, two of them against brokers who turned away applicants with housing vouchers (release). The amounts are in NYC brokers fined for voucher discrimination.
What the Case Was About
The case is an enforcement proceeding the Attorney General brought against Ithaca landlords who would not rent to Section 8 voucher holders. Its name is Matter of People of the State of New York v Commons West, LLC (official report, 2026 NY Slip Op 01253).
- The facts. "In 2020, two prospective tenants filed complaints" saying the respondents, "the owners of residential rental properties in the City of Ithaca," had refused to rent to them because they received Section 8 assistance.
- The claim. The Attorney General sued under Executive Law 63(12), alleging violations of Executive Law 296(5)(a)(1). The State asked for an injunction, nondiscrimination policies, a three-year set-aside of units for Section 8 households, court monitoring, restitution and civil penalties.
- The trial court. Supreme Court, Tompkins County (Masler, J.) dismissed the petition by judgment entered June 28, 2023. By judgment entered December 11, 2024 it granted the landlords a declaration that the provision is unconstitutional on its face.
- The appeal. The Third Department heard the case on January 8, 2026 and affirmed both judgments on March 5, 2026. Justice Ceresia wrote. Presiding Justice Garry and Justices Fisher, McShan and Mackey concurred.

- April 12, 2019New York adds lawful source of income to the State Human Rights Law (Attorney General)
- 2020two prospective tenants complain to the Attorney General about Ithaca rentals (Third Department opinion, page 3)
- 2022the Attorney General sues Jason Fane, Ithaca Renting Company and related companies (Attorney General release)
- June 28, 2023Supreme Court, Tompkins County, enters judgment dismissing the petition (opinion, page 2)
- December 11, 2024the same court denies renewal and again declares the provision facially unconstitutional as to Section 8 vouchers (2024 NY Slip Op 24316, 85 Misc 3d 1055)
- January 8, 2026the Third Department hears the appeal (opinion, page 1)
- March 5, 2026the Third Department affirms, "without costs" (CV-23-1255). The Attorney General says: "We are reviewing today's decision"
- April 1, 2026notice of appeal to the Court of Appeals filed in Tompkins County, according to an Attorney General spokesperson quoted by the Ithaca Times
- May 21, 2026Court of Appeals, Motion No. 2026-264: stay "denied as unnecessary" (2026 NY Slip Op 68687)
- August 24 and 27, 2026dates on two friend-of-the-court briefs in the Court of Appeals, posted by the Legal Aid Society and PRRAC
- October 7, 2026no Commons West decision appears on the Court of Appeals' decision lists, which run through September 24, 2026
What it means: both courts that have ruled on the merits ruled for the landlords, and the State's highest court has not yet decided the appeal.
Source: as linked in each entry; compiled by VoucherMatch.
Why the Court Struck It Down
The court held that the State provision "violates landlords' Fourth Amendment rights to be free from unlawful searches." Its reasoning turns on what a landlord must agree to in order to take part in the federal Section 8 program.
- 1The law requires participationthe Legislature "passed a law prohibiting discrimination against potential tenants based on their source of income, effectively requiring landlords to participate in the Section 8 program."
- 2Participation requires inspectionsthe housing agency "must perform an inspection of the apartment, the equipment that services the apartment and the common areas of the building before the apartment is occupied and again not less than biennially."
- 3Participation requires access to recordsthe landlord must sign a standard contract "in which it agrees to provide 'full and free access' to the apartment, the premises and all relevant accounts and records."
- 4So the search is compelled indirectly"although the source-of-income discrimination law does not, itself, require any searches, they are indirectly compelled through the terms of the Section 8 program and the HAP contract."
- 5Result"landlords are now forced to consent to governmental searches of their rental properties and records," and "we are constrained to conclude that the law is unconstitutional on its face."
What it means: the issue was participation in the federal program. The opinion discusses no other voucher program.
Source: Third Department opinion, pages 2, 3, 5 and 6, citing 42 USC 1437f(o)(8), 24 CFR 982.405 and 982.507, and Sokolov v Village of Freeport, 52 NY2d 341 (1981).
The same opinion called the Legislature's effort "deliberate" and "laudable," and acknowledged that "source-of-income discrimination is often a proxy for discrimination against other protected classes." It then rejected each of the Attorney General's arguments.
| The State argued | The court's answer |
|---|---|
| The landlords were never inspected, so the harm is speculative | A party may sue "when there is a credible threat that the government will enforce" the law against them. The State was already seeking set-asides, monitoring and penalties |
| The statute does not authorize any search on its face | Under Sokolov, inspections "indirectly made a condition" of renting still count |
| A housing agency could get tenant consent or a warrant | "This argument misses the mark." The inquiry is "searches that the law actually authorizes" (Los Angeles v Patel) |
| A landlord can go to court first, under CPLR article 78 | "Such a proffered remedy, however, is toothless," because the landlord has already consented in writing, and the agency may suspend payments at once |
| Rental housing is a closely regulated industry | Sokolov held it is not, "a ruling that has not since been overturned." "Even assuming, without deciding," that it is, the inspection regime lacks limits on "time, place, and scope" |
| The State housing agency adopted a consent-or-warrant policy for Tompkins County | "This policy does not cure the facial unconstitutionality." It "is merely voluntary and does not have the force of law" |
| Read the HAP contract narrowly | "Unpreserved for review," and contrary to the contract's "must" and "shall" |
What it means: inspection rules are the core of the ruling. How to screen Section 8 tenants and HPD vs NYCHA Section 8 cover how those inspections and contracts work in the five boroughs.
Source: Third Department opinion, pages 4 to 9.
What the Ruling Does Not Change
The declaration is limited by its own words to one State provision and one kind of income: Section 8 vouchers.
| Question | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Executive Law 296(5)(a)(1), refusing to rent "because their source of income includes Section 8 vouchers" | Covered: declared "facially unconstitutional to the extent" quoted | Opinion, page 9 |
| Facial or as-applied? | Facial. The trial court's "ruling was limited to the facial challenge" | Opinion, footnote 1; 2024 NY Slip Op 24316 |
| The landlords' separate as-applied challenge | Not decided | Opinion, footnote 1 |
| Other lawful income in Executive Law 292(36): child support, alimony, foster care subsidies, Social Security, other public or housing assistance | Not covered by the declaration's wording. The opinion discusses only the Section 8 program | Opinion, page 9; Executive Law 292(36) |
| CityFHEPS, FHEPS, HASA | Not mentioned in the opinion. The City Commissioner: the arguments "don't apply" to them | Commission transcript, May 4, 2026 |
| NYC Human Rights Law, Administrative Code 8-107(5) | Not mentioned in the opinion. The City Commissioner: "It doesn't apply to the New York City law directly" | Opinion (full text searched); Commission transcript |
| Whether rental housing is now a closely regulated industry | Not decided: "Even assuming, without deciding" | Opinion, page 7 |
| How far the ruling reaches outside the Third Department | Not stated in the opinion. No agency statement was found | Opinion; agency pages read October 7, 2026 |
| Whether the State may enforce the provision during the appeal | The Court of Appeals called a stay "unnecessary," citing CPLR 5519(a)(1), and gave no further explanation | 2026 NY Slip Op 68687 |
What it means: for a CityFHEPS, FHEPS or HASA holder, nothing in the opinion addresses the program. Is CityFHEPS Section 8? explains which voucher is which.
Source: as shown in each row; compiled by VoucherMatch on October 7, 2026.
About the records
Where the Appeal Stands
The appeal is pending at the Court of Appeals, New York's highest court, and no argument date or decision was found as of October 7, 2026.
- How it got there. by a notice of appeal filed April 1, 2026, according to the Attorney General's office as quoted by the Ithaca Times on April 17. The notice itself, on the State's e-filing site, could not be opened.
- The stay order. the Court of Appeals ruled, in full: "Motion for a stay &c. denied as unnecessary (see CPLR 5519 [a] [1]; Colonial Arms Apts. v Village of Mount Kisco, 64 NY2d 948, 949 [1985])."
- The provision the Court cited. CPLR 5519(a)(1) says service of "a notice of appeal or an affidavit of intention to move for permission to appeal stays all proceedings to enforce the judgment or order appealed from pending the appeal" where "the appellant or moving party is the state." (CPLR 5519)
- Briefing. briefs filed in August 2026 carry the number APL-2026-00035.
- Argument date. not found. The Court lists argument days on October 20, 21 and 22 and November 17, 18 and 19, 2026. Its calendars naming the cases are PDF files that could not be opened, so VoucherMatch cannot say whether Commons West is on them.
- Decision. not found. The Court's decision lists for April through September 2026 name each case decided, and Commons West is not among them. No October 2026 decisions were posted as of October 7.
- By leave or as of right. not confirmed. The Court's weekly list of new filings states the basis for each appeal, and that list is also a PDF that could not be opened.
What it means: the Court has said a stay order was unnecessary and has cited the statute above. It has not said anything more about what the State may enforce in the meantime, and neither has the Attorney General.
Source: Court of Appeals motion decision, May 21, 2026; Court of Appeals October 2026 calendar page and September 2026 decisions; PRRAC filing page.

Could the Same Argument Reach the NYC Law?
No court has said so, and the City Commission says it is continuing to enforce the City law. VoucherMatch found no decision applying Commons West to Administrative Code 8-107(5) and no agency statement predicting one, as of October 7, 2026.
The Commissioner said on May 4 that the ruling "largely rested on this requirement in Section 8 that says to participate, landlords have to open up their records for inspection." Whether that reasoning could be raised against the City law is a question no court or agency document found has answered.
Outside the Five Boroughs
The opinion does not say where in the State it applies, and no agency has published a statement on that point. The agencies' public pages still invite Section 8 reports statewide.
- State Division of Human Rights: its Section 8 page, as served on October 7, 2026, says: "If housing providers refuse to rent or sell to you, or 'ghost' you because you plan to pay with a Section 8 voucher, report it to us by calling (844) 697-3471." The page does not mention the ruling.
- Attorney General: the source of income page still lists "any form of federal, state, or local housing assistance (such as Section 8 vouchers)" as protected and links a complaint form.
- Homes and Community Renewal: the opinion describes a policy for Tompkins County under which the agency "will not rely on the contract to gain access," and holds that the policy "does not apply statewide."
- Local laws: the opinion mentions no county or municipal source-of-income law. VoucherMatch did not survey local laws outside New York City.
What the Agencies Have Published Since the Ruling
Two agencies have spoken about the ruling by name: the Attorney General on March 5 and the City Commission on May 4. No statement naming it was found from the others.
| Agency | What it has published | Date |
|---|---|---|
| NYS Attorney General | "My office has always fought to protect New Yorkers' right to housing. We are reviewing today's decision." No press release on the appeal was found | March 5, 2026 |
| NYC Commission on Human Rights | "It doesn't apply to the New York City law directly ... I feel very confident in our continued enforcement of that law." | May 4, 2026 |
| NYS Division of Human Rights | No statement naming the ruling among its 2026 press release headlines or legal notices. Its April 7, 2026 fair housing release does not mention it | Read October 7, 2026 |
| NYCHA | None found. Its Section 8 tenant page says the City Commission "enforces the City Human Rights Law," and that lawful source of income includes "section 8 vouchers" | Read October 7, 2026 |
| HPD | None found on its Section 8 owner and rights pages | Read October 7, 2026 |
| HRA | None found. Its page says "a landlord cannot refuse to rent you an apartment because you are paying with" FHEPS, CityFHEPS, Section 8 or Cash Assistance | Read October 7, 2026 |
What it means: no agency has told Section 8 holders to stop reporting refusals, and none has published guidance on what the ruling changes in practice.
Source: Attorney General statement; Commission transcript; Division of Human Rights pressroom and legal notices; NYCHA; HPD; HRA.
Where a Voucher Holder Can Still File a Complaint Today
All three enforcement agencies were taking source-of-income reports on October 7, 2026, according to their own pages.
| Agency | Its own statement | How |
|---|---|---|
| NYC Commission on Human Rights | "If you experience source of income discrimination, we can help." | Dial 311 and ask for "Human Rights," call 212-416-0197, or use the report form |
| NYS Division of Human Rights | "Facing discrimination because you use Section 8? Report it by calling (844) 697-3471." If early intervention fails, the voucher holder "may still be able to file a formal complaint" | Call 844-697-3471 or use dhr.ny.gov/report |
| NYS Attorney General | "Filing a complaint does not start a lawsuit on your behalf. We will keep your information on file in case we identify a pattern" | Source-of-income complaint form |
What it means: the Division's page does not say how it is handling Section 8 complaints after the ruling. Deadlines and filing steps are in how to report voucher discrimination in NYC.
Source: Commission source of income page; Division Section 8 page; Attorney General complaint form.
What to Tell a Landlord Client Who Brings It Up
No agency has published guidance for brokers about the ruling, so the only sourced answer is what the court and the Commission have each said.
- What was struck. one State provision, "to the extent" it covers Section 8 vouchers (Third Department, March 5, 2026)
- Status. on appeal, with a stay "denied as unnecessary" (Court of Appeals, May 21, 2026)
- City law. "It doesn't apply to the New York City law directly" (City Commissioner, May 4, 2026)
- Enforcement. two brokers were ordered to pay damages and penalties in City voucher decisions announced August 4, 2026
The Commission's broker FAQ, a file dated January 2020, predates the ruling. It tells brokers to "keep a log of any owners who make unlawful denials" and "notify the Commission of any potential violations." It adds that "willful violations can carry a civil penalty of up to $250,000 per violation" and that the Commission "may report a licensed agent who has violated the law to the Department of State's Division of Licensing Services."
Broker duties under State licensing rules are in how to become a CityFHEPS broker, and fee rules are in the FARE Act and voucher broker fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can NYC landlords refuse Section 8 now?
The ruling does not say so. It addresses a State provision and does not mention the City's Human Rights Law, which the City Commission says it continues to enforce. The City rule is explained in can a landlord refuse Section 8 in NYC.
Was the decision unanimous?
Yes. Five justices sat. Justice Ceresia wrote the opinion, and Presiding Justice Garry and Justices Fisher, McShan and Mackey concurred.
Does it matter that the landlords had never been inspected?
The court said no. It found "a credible threat that the government will enforce" the law against them, because "this very proceeding resulted from petitioner's attempt to enforce" it.
What happens if the Court of Appeals reverses?
No court or agency has said. The effect would depend on the terms of the Court of Appeals' own decision, which had not been issued as of October 7, 2026.
Where can a voucher holder report discrimination in NYC?
The NYC Commission on Human Rights: dial 311 and ask for "Human Rights," or call 212-416-0197. The State Division of Human Rights takes reports at 844-697-3471.
Sources
Each claim above links to its document. The two that carry the case are the Third Department opinion and order of March 5, 2026 and the Court of Appeals motion decision of May 21, 2026.
TipThe next document to watch for is a Court of Appeals decision or argument calendar naming the case. Until then, a voucher holder looking in the five boroughs can browse Section 8 apartments and current listings from landlords who take vouchers.
TipBrokers who work with voucher holders can join VoucherMatch's broker directory.
How this article was checked
Last checked: October 7, 2026, against the Third Department's opinion and order (CV-23-1255, 2026 NY Slip Op 01253); the Court of Appeals motion decision (2026 NY Slip Op 68687); the Tompkins County Supreme Court decision of December 11, 2024 (2024 NY Slip Op 24316); CPLR 5519 and Executive Law 292; the Court of Appeals' monthly decision lists and calendar pages; the Attorney General's statement of March 5, 2026; the City Commission on Human Rights' transcript of May 4, 2026 and release of August 4, 2026; and the current pages of the State Division of Human Rights, NYCHA, HPD and HRA. nycourts.gov and nysenate.gov pages were read through the r.jina.ai browser engine. General information, not legal advice.
Sources for this article (28)
- Third Department opinion, March 5, 2026 (decisions.courts.state.ny.us)
- transcript of the Brian Lehrer Show, May 4, 2026 (nyc.gov)
- statement of March 5, 2026 (ag.ny.gov)
- release (nyc.gov)
- official report, 2026 NY Slip Op 01253 (nycourts.gov)
- Attorney General (ag.ny.gov)
- Attorney General release (ag.ny.gov)
- 2024 NY Slip Op 24316, 85 Misc 3d 1055 (nycourts.gov)
- Ithaca Times (ithaca.com)
- 2026 NY Slip Op 68687 (nycourts.gov)
- Legal Aid Society (legalaidnyc.org)
- PRRAC (prrac.org)
- Executive Law 292(36) (nysenate.gov)
- CPLR 5519 (nysenate.gov)
- October 2026 calendar page (nycourts.gov)
- September 2026 decisions (nycourts.gov)
- PRRAC filing page (prrac.org)
- Section 8 page (dhr.ny.gov)
- pressroom (dhr.ny.gov)
- legal notices (dhr.ny.gov)
- NYCHA (nyc.gov)
- HPD (nyc.gov)
- HRA (nyc.gov)
- report form (nyc.gov)
- dhr.ny.gov/report (dhr.ny.gov)
- Source-of-income complaint form (ag.ny.gov)
- source of income page (nyc.gov)
- broker FAQ (nyc.gov)
Stay Updated on Housing
Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.
VoucherMatch Editorial Team
Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected
Find apartments
Listings on VoucherMatch come from landlords who say up front which vouchers they accept.
Related Articles
Section 8 Rent Limits in West Virginia for FY2027: Fair Market Rent for Every County
HUD's FY2027 2-bedroom rent limit in West Virginia runs from $944 (Barbour County) to $1,505 (Hampshire County), median $955. Every county's figure by bedroom size, what changed from FY2026, the largest housing authorities, and the voucher law.
10 min readRenting With Section 8 in Upper West Side, Manhattan: 2026 Guide
Section 8 on the Upper West Side: NYCHA's $2,997 and HPD's ZIP code standards (10023, 10024, 10025, 10069), the 40% rule and live listings, 2026.
7 min readWhat Counts as Income for Section 8? What Is Included, What Is Excluded, and Child Support (2026)
Section 8 counts nearly all money that regularly comes into the household from outside it, including wages, benefits, child support you actually receive and business profit. HUD's 2023 income rule also lists 28 categories that do not count, from a minor's paychecks to tax refunds, gifts for birthdays and one-time payments. Here is the full picture, with the deductions that lower the number your rent is based on.
9 min readWhat Happens to Section 8 If Your Income Goes Up?
After you receive a voucher, a raise does not end it. Your share rises about 30 cents per added dollar. See when to report, the 2027 rule and the 180-day clock.
18 min readSection 8 Interim Change in NYC: How to Report Income Changes
Report an income change mid-year in NYC: NYCHA within 30 days on the Self-Service Portal, HCR within 10 business days, and HPD's decrease form.
17 min readSection 8 Income Limits NYC 2026: 1 to 8 People (HUD)
Section 8 income limits in NYC for 2026: $59,400 for one person, $84,800 for four (HUD FY2026). See the full table, who qualifies and what counts as income.
10 min readExplore the NYC broker workspace
Keep your client’s housing search moving with practical guides and the right workspace.