Can You Rent an Apartment in NYC With an Eviction on Your Record?

Yes, and if you have a housing voucher, your odds are better than you think. An eviction case in your past, even one you lost, does not legally bar you from renting in New York, and state law actually restricts how landlords can use housing-court history against you. But the practical reality is messier than the legal one, so this guide covers both: what the law says, and what actually works.

What Landlords See When They Screen You

Most NYC landlords run applicants through tenant screening reports. These reports pull from credit bureaus and from housing-court records, and an eviction filing can show up whether or not you lost the case. A case that was dismissed, settled, or discontinued can still appear as a filing.

That's the core unfairness these reports create: they often don't distinguish between "was evicted for nonpayment" and "was sued once, won, and stayed." Know what's in your record before a landlord does. You can search New York court records yourself through the court system's public portals, and if a screening report about you contains errors, you have the right to dispute it with the screening company under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act.

What New York Law Says

Two protections matter here:

Housing-court history ("tenant blacklist") protection. Since New York's 2019 tenant protection laws, Real Property Law §227-f provides that a landlord who refuses to rent to someone because of a past landlord-tenant court case faces a rebuttable presumption that the refusal was based on that history, which the law prohibits. In plain terms: denying you because you've been to housing court is unlawful, and if a landlord requests court records and then denies you, the law presumes that's why.

Source-of-income protection. If you have a voucher (Section 8, CityFHEPS, FHEPS, HASA, or any lawful subsidy), refusing you because of the voucher has been illegal in NYC since 2008 under the NYC Human Rights Law. Landlords sometimes use a past eviction as cover for what is really voucher discrimination. The NYC Commission on Human Rights investigates both.

Neither law forces a landlord to rent to you, and landlords can still consider things like income and credit. But the law is on your side more than most applicants with an eviction history realize.

Why a Voucher Changes the Math

Think about what an eviction record signals to a landlord: risk of unpaid rent. Now think about what a voucher does: the government pays most of the rent directly to the landlord, every month, regardless of what happens in the tenant's life.

If your voucher covers 70% of the rent and your share is based on 30% of your income, the landlord's actual exposure is a fraction of what it would be with a market tenant, and the subsidized portion arrives even in months when a market tenant might have fallen behind. For a landlord reading applications rationally, a voucher holder with an old eviction is often lower-risk than an unsubsidized applicant with a clean record, because most of the rent doesn't depend on the tenant at all.

Make this argument explicitly when you apply. Don't hope the landlord figures it out.

Practical Steps That Work

1. Get ahead of the record. Mention the eviction before the landlord finds it, with a one-paragraph explanation: what happened, why, and what's different now. A job loss during COVID that led to arrears, since resolved, reads very differently when you explain it than when it's a bare court record.

2. Bring proof of the resolution. If you paid off the arrears, bring the receipt or satisfaction. If the case was dismissed or settled, bring the stipulation. If a One-Shot Deal paid the arrears, bring that paperwork; our guide on applying for a One-Shot Deal explains that program.

3. Lead with the voucher. State the program, your share of the rent, and the fact that the subsidy is paid directly to the landlord. If a caseworker or housing specialist can vouch for you, a short letter from them helps.

4. Apply where vouchers are wanted. The single biggest time-saver: skip landlords you'd have to convince. Every landlord on VoucherMatch is there specifically to rent to voucher holders, which means the conversation starts from "how do we make this work" instead of "why should I take the risk."

5. If you're denied, ask why in writing. A written reason creates accountability. If the stated reason is your court history or your voucher, that's evidence for a complaint to the NYC Commission on Human Rights (call 311 and ask for Human Rights, or call 212-416-0197).

If the Eviction Case Is Still Open

An open case is a different situation: solve it before or alongside your apartment search.

• Free lawyers exist for this. NYC's Right to Counsel program provides free legal representation to income-eligible tenants in eviction cases. Call 311 and ask about Right to Counsel, or contact The Legal Aid Society.
• Arrears help exists. A One-Shot Deal can pay rent arrears and stop a nonpayment case. Homebase offices help tenants at risk of eviction with arrears, mediation, and benefits.
• A voucher can be part of the resolution. CityFHEPS exists partly to prevent evictions; if you're at risk of losing your home, ask Homebase or your caseworker whether you qualify. Our guide on how to apply for CityFHEPS covers the process.

What Landlords Should Take From This

If you're a landlord screening a voucher holder with an eviction filing in their past, look at the substance before the headline. A filing is not a judgment; a years-old nonpayment case followed by stable tenancy is not a red flag; and the subsidized share of the rent arrives regardless. Denying an applicant because of housing-court history invites liability under RPL §227-f, and denying because of the voucher violates the NYC Human Rights Law.

Screen on what actually predicts performance: current income against their share of the rent, the subsidy amount, and references. Our guide on screening Section 8 tenants covers what you can and can't consider.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an eviction disqualify me from getting a voucher? No. An eviction from private housing doesn't bar you from Section 8, CityFHEPS, or HASA. Owing money to a public housing authority is a different issue and can affect Section 8 eligibility until resolved.

How long does an eviction stay on my record? Housing-court records are long-lived, and screening reports commonly show cases going back years. There's no automatic expungement of eviction records in New York, which is why explanation and documentation matter more than waiting for the record to disappear.

Can a landlord legally deny me for a dismissed case? Denying you because of your landlord-tenant court history, including dismissed cases, is exactly what RPL §227-f targets. If it happens, ask for the reason in writing and consider filing a complaint.

My screening report shows an eviction that isn't mine. What do I do? Dispute it with the screening company in writing; the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires them to investigate. Mixed files (someone else's case attached to your name) are a known problem with these reports.

Will VoucherMatch landlords see my eviction record? Landlords make their own screening decisions. The difference is that landlords here already want voucher tenants, so the subsidy conversation is settled before the screening conversation starts. Browse listings and apply with your explanation ready.

---

Searching with a voucher? Browse voucher-friendly listings from landlords who want what you bring: government-backed rent.

Are you a landlord? List your property free and reach thousands of voucher holders searching right now.