Skip to page content

How to Screen Section 8 Tenants in NYC: What the Law Allows

Checked October 7, 202612 min readBy VoucherMatch Editorial Team
A large white stone courthouse with a columned entrance beside a newer white stone and glass court building, with flags flying in front under a blue sky
The state Supreme Court and Civil Court buildings on Sutphin Boulevard in Jamaica, Queens, March 2019. Photo: CaptJayRuffins, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).
Quick answerIn New York City, as of October 2026, screening a tenant with a Section 8 voucher is the owner's job: the housing agency checks program eligibility only (24 CFR 982.307). The owner may check references and, where the tenant pays part of the rent, credit. City and State rules bar a minimum income or guarantor, refusal over housing court history, any fee above $20 and a criminal check before a conditional offer.
Screening limits in six numbers
  • $20most a landlord may charge for a background and credit check, or the actual cost if lower
  • 30 dayshow recent an applicant's own report must be for the fee to be waived
  • 1 month's rentthe most a landlord may take as a deposit or advance
  • 5 years and 3 yearshow far back a felony or a misdemeanor conviction may be reviewed
  • 5 business daystime an applicant has to answer a criminal record before an offer is withdrawn
  • $250,000top City civil penalty for a willful violation

What the Housing Authority Already Screens

The housing agency screens for program eligibility, and the federal rule leaves the rest to the owner. The agency "has no liability or responsibility to the owner or other persons for the family's behavior or suitability for tenancy," and "the owner is responsible for screening and selection of the family" (24 CFR 982.307(a)).

Who checks what
  • The agency checks eligibilitythat the household is a family, is income-eligible and meets the citizenship or immigration rule (24 CFR 982.201), and that no member is barred for lifetime sex offender registration, for making methamphetamine in federally assisted housing, or by the three-year bar after a drug-related eviction from federally assisted housing (24 CFR 982.553)
  • The agency tells the ownerthe family's current and prior address, and the name and address, if known, of the landlord at each (982.307(b)(1))
  • The agency keeps to itselfNYCHA's plan says it runs a criminal background and sex offender check and "does not provide this information to owners." HPD's plan says it "will not provide any additional information about the applicant household"
  • The owner may look atpayment of rent and utility bills, care of the unit, respect for other residents' peaceful enjoyment, drug-related or threatening criminal activity, and compliance with other essential conditions of tenancy (982.307(a)(3))

What it means: the federal list is permission to screen, and New York law then limits each item on it.

Source: 24 CFR 982.201, 982.307 and 982.553; NYCHA Administrative Plan, May 2026, sections V.C and XIV.A; HPD Administrative Plan, April 2025, section 11.1.4. HCR's plan was not read.

Item 13 of the Request for Tenancy Approval, form HUD-52517, repeats the point: "The PHA has not screened the family's behavior or suitability for tenancy. Such screening is the owner's responsibility." The agency's own denial rules are in what disqualifies an applicant from Section 8.

Your Screening Process Must Be Consistent

A consistent process is required, and in New York City consistency alone does not make a rule lawful. City law bars refusing to rent, or setting different "terms, conditions or privileges," because of "any lawful source of income" (Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(a)). The Commission on Human Rights' landlord FAQ also treats some rules as violations even when every applicant faces them.

What New York law allows for each screening tool, as read October 7, 2026
ToolWhat New York law allowsCitation
Application feeOnly for a background and credit check: the actual cost or $20, whichever is less, with a copy of the report and the receipt or invoiceReal Property Law 238-a(1)
Applicant's own reportThe landlord "shall waive the fee" for a check from the past 30 daysReal Property Law 238-a(1)(b)
Income questions"It is not unlawful to ask about income, only to discriminate based on lawful sources of income"State Division of Human Rights notice
Minimum incomeNone where the program sets the tenant's share from income: "it is a violation of the Law to impose any additional income requirements"Commission landlord FAQ
Guarantor or co-signer"You may not require guarantors or co-signers"Commission landlord FAQ
Credit checkNo rejection on credit where the voucher covers 100% of the rent. An inquiry is allowed where the tenant pays a share. A required score "is evidence of discrimination"Commission landlord FAQ
Housing court historyNo refusal over a past or pending landlord-tenant case. Checking court records or a screening bureau and then refusing creates a rebuttable presumption of a violationReal Property Law 227-f
Screening bureau scoresNot alone: "Applicants must be considered on a case-by-case basis"Commission landlord FAQ
Landlord referencesAllowed: payment of rent and care of the unit are named factors24 CFR 982.307(a)(3)
Criminal historyOnly after a written conditional offer and the City's notice. Only registry offenses, felonies within 5 years and misdemeanors within 3Admin. Code 8-102, 8-107(5)(o)
Security depositNo deposit or advance above one month's rent. NYCHA: no higher than for tenants outside the programGeneral Obligations Law 7-108(1-a)(a); NYCHA owner guide
Money before move-inNo "additional fees, deposits, or rent until the applicant has been approved to move in by the agency"Commission landlord FAQ

What it means: a 650 credit score or a "40 times the rent" rule applied to every applicant is still a problem when the applicant holds a voucher.

Source: as cited in each row; State statutes read on nysenate.gov; Commission FAQ dated March 2023. Compiled by VoucherMatch.

Watch outA small building does not exempt a landlord from the City law.Building size is no shelter. The City's five-or-fewer-unit exception ended on February 15, 2021, and two narrow owner-occupied exemptions remain: see can a landlord refuse Section 8 in NYC. A March 5, 2026 appeals ruling on the State law is under appeal, and the opinion does not mention the City law. The Commons West article follows it.

Building a Compliant Screening Process

A compliant process runs in a fixed order, because City law puts the criminal check last.

A lawful screening sequence in New York City, from application to decision
  1. 1Write the criteriathe same review for every applicant, without the barred tests in the table above
  2. 2Take the applicationon the same terms as any caller, with a fee of $20 or less
  3. 3Review general eligibilityreferences, and credit only where the tenant pays a share
  4. 4Decide on those groundsa refusal goes in writing, with the consumer report notice
  5. 5Make the conditional offera lease or rental agreement that commits the unit, with the Fair Chance Housing Notice if a criminal check will follow
  6. 6Run the criminal check, if anyreviewable convictions only
  7. 7Before withdrawingthe records to the applicant, and five business days to respond
  8. 8Assess and decidean individualized assessment, then a written reason
  9. 9Send the paperwork to the agencyno further money until it approves the move-in

What it means: steps 6 to 8 apply only to an owner who chooses to run a criminal check. The Commission's page says the law "DOES NOT require" one.

Source: VoucherMatch's ordering of Real Property Law 238-a, the Commission's landlord FAQ, Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(o) and FTC guidance.

A three-story tan and orange brick building with arched windows and fire escapes, apartments above a corner deli with a maroon awning, and street trees in front
A three-story brick building with apartments above a corner deli in the Cypress Avenue West Historic District in Ridgewood, Queens, September 2013. Photo: ALT55 - Victor M, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Step 1: Document Your Criteria

Written criteria show that each applicant was measured the same way, and they are the place to remove rules New York does not allow. NYCHA's plan says only that owners "are encouraged to screen households on the basis of their tenant application standards."

  • Can hold: landlord references on rent paid, care of the unit and lease compliance, and a credit review without a cut-off score for applicants who will pay part of the rent
  • Cannot hold: the barred tests in the table above, "working" Section 8 only, one program and not another, or any statement about criminal background checks

Source: Commission on Human Rights landlord FAQ; Administrative Code 8-107(5)(o)(1)(D). What it means: the owner answers for brokers and supers too. The FAQ says: "You are responsible for the actions of anyone who plays a role in processing applications for your rental units."

Step 2: Verify Income Correctly

For a Section 8 applicant, verifying income means confirming the voucher, with no income minimum added. The Commission's reasoning: "When a voucher program calculates a tenants' rent based on their income, the government has already determined that they can afford to pay their required portion."

  • The condition: the Commission's tenant FAQ says no rejection for insufficient income if "your voucher program would approve the monthly rent" and the voucher sets the tenant's portion from income, "like Section 8"
  • Who pays what: how landlords get paid under Section 8

Step 3: Run a Credit Check

A credit check is allowed only where the tenant will pay part of the rent, and never with a pass mark. The Commission's landlord FAQ of March 2023, its current guidance on credit and voucher holders, reads:

Key point"If the voucher/subsidy covers 100% of the rent, you may not reject an applicant based on credit history or score. If the applicants pay a portion of the rent, you may make a credit inquiry. Requiring a specific credit score, however, is evidence of discrimination. Each application should be considered on a case-by-case basis. Prior to rejecting an applicant based on credit, the applicant should be provided an opportunity to demonstrate ability to timely pay their portion of the rent."
  • Written explanation: "To protect yourself under the Law and comply with federal law when making a decision based on a credit report, provide the applicant a written explanation of your analysis"
  • Where the rule sits: in Commission guidance. No separate credit provision for housing was found in the text of section 8-107(5)

Step 4: Check Rental History, Leaving Out Housing Court Cases

References from current and prior landlords are the screening federal rules point owners to, and housing court history is the part New York removes. Real Property Law 227-f says no landlord "shall refuse to rent or offer a lease to a potential tenant on the basis that the potential tenant was involved in a past or pending landlord-tenant action or summary proceeding."

  • The presumption: a violation is presumed if a person "requested information from a tenant screening bureau relating to a potential tenant or otherwise inspected court records" and "subsequently refuses to rent." The text has no exception for a pattern of cases
  • The penalty: $500 to $1,000 for each violation, in a case brought by the Attorney General
  • Screening companies: the Commission warns that "use of data from TSBs may disproportionally exclude voucher holders"
Reference questions tied to 24 CFR 982.307(a)(3)
  • Was the rent paid, and were utility bills paid?
  • How was the apartment kept?
  • Were there complaints from other residents about noise or disturbance?
  • Were the other terms of the lease followed?

Renting with an eviction record in NYC explains what screening reports show. The Section 8 eviction process in NYC covers what an owner can do once a tenancy has started.

Step 5: Conduct a Criminal Background Check

A criminal background check is optional, and since January 1, 2025 it may come only after a conditional offer. The Fair Chance Housing Act (Local Law 24 of 2024) is Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(o). Asking an applicant about a record, in writing or aloud, counts as a check, according to the Commission's Fair Chance Housing page.

Fair Chance Housing: the order the statute sets
  • Before any checkreview everything else and give the applicant "a rental or lease agreement that commits the housing accommodation to the applicant" (8-107(5)(o)(4)(B))
  • With the offernotice of the check and a written copy of the City's Fair Chance Housing Notice (8-107(5)(o)(4)(C))
  • The checkreviewable criminal history only
  • Before adverse actiona written copy of the records relied on and of any other criminal history received, with notice of five business days to point out errors and send "supplemental or mitigating information" (8-107(5)(o)(5))
  • After the five business days"an individualized assessment" of the reviewable history and what the applicant sent (8-107(5)(o)(6)(A))
  • To withdraw the offerthe supporting documents and a written statement showing how the history "is relevant to a legitimate business interest of the property owner" and how the applicant's information "was taken into account" (8-107(5)(o)(6)(B))

What it means: the Commission says the unit stays committed to the applicant while the process runs, and that "the existence of a conviction alone never creates that link."

Source: Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(o), as posted by the Commission on Human Rights.

What may be reviewed, Administrative Code section 8-102
  • Reviewablea conviction on the New York, federal or another jurisdiction's sex offense registry
  • Reviewablea felony conviction where less than five years have passed since release from incarceration, or since sentencing if there was none
  • Reviewablea misdemeanor conviction where less than three years have passed, counted the same way
  • Never reviewablearrests, pending cases, adjournments in contemplation of dismissal, youthful offender and juvenile adjudications, non-criminal violations, and convictions that were sealed, expunged, pardoned, vacated or covered by a certificate of relief from disabilities

Two more points sit in the statute:

  • Presumption: knowingly receiving anything outside the reviewable list "creates a rebuttable presumption" that it was relied on, and the owner must "take reasonable steps" to keep a screening company's check within the law (8-107(5)(o)(7))
  • Immunity: an owner is "immune from liability in any civil action" over renting to someone with a record or not running a check (8-107(5)(o)(9))
Watch outIt is unsettled whether the federal criminal screening rule protects a private owner.The federal rule lets an owner consider "drug-related criminal activity or other criminal activity that is a threat to the health, safety or property of others." The City law excuses actions "required or specifically authorized" by federal or State law, with conditions (8-107(5)(o)(3)). VoucherMatch found no Commission statement on whether the federal screening rule qualifies for a private owner.

Step 6: Interview the Applicant

An interview is allowed and belongs before the conditional offer, with the rest of the eligibility review.

  • Source of income: an inquiry may not express "any limitation, specification or discrimination" on that ground (section 8-107(5)(a)(2))
  • Criminal history: no question before the conditional offer
  • Same questions for everyone: drawn from the written criteria, with the answers noted in the file

Income Calculation Example

No income multiple applies to a Section 8 applicant, so the only figure that matters is the tenant's share.

ExampleThese figures are hypothetical. The rent is $2,200. The agency pays $1,700 and sets the tenant's share at $500 from the tenant's income. A "40 times the rent" rule would ask for $88,000 a year against the full rent, or $20,000 against the share (VoucherMatch's arithmetic: 40 x $2,200 and 40 x $500). The Commission's FAQ treats either test as an added income requirement, and so as a violation, for this applicant.

What to Do If You Deny an Applicant

A denial needs a lawful reason, stated in writing, and the notice federal law requires when a report was used. Voucher status, a missed income multiple, a housing court case and a non-reviewable criminal record are not available reasons, and the Commission treats a required credit score as evidence of discrimination.

What a denial file should show
  • The reason. tied to the written criteria and to what a reference or document showed
  • Credit. proof the tenant pays a share, the chance given to show ability to pay it, and the written explanation
  • Consumer report notice. the reporting company's name, address and phone; a statement that it did not make the decision; the right to dispute and to a free copy within 60 days
  • Criminal history. the six Fair Chance steps, each dated

What it means: the FTC says the notice is required "even if information in the consumer report wasn't the primary reason for the decision," and calls a written notice "the best practice."

Source: FTC, Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know; Commission landlord FAQ.

The City can impose a civil penalty of up to $125,000, or $250,000 for a willful, wanton or malicious act (section 8-126). The applicant's side is in how to report voucher discrimination in NYC.

A curving row of four-story brownstone and painted row houses with tall stoops and iron railings, bare trees and parked cars along the street
Row houses at 19 to 43 West 130th Street, between Fifth and Lenox avenues in Harlem, Manhattan, March 2014. Photo: Beyond My Ken, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Documentation to Request

Ask a voucher applicant for the same documents as anyone else, plus the voucher paperwork.

  • Identification: the same as for any applicant
  • The voucher and the Request for Tenancy Approval: form HUD-52517, for the agency
  • Current and prior addresses and landlords: the agency supplies these too
  • Consent for a credit check: only where the tenant will pay a share
  • Consent for a criminal check: not before the conditional offer

Security deposits and up-front money

A deposit is allowed and capped at one month's rent. General Obligations Law 7-108(1-a)(a) says "No deposit or advance shall exceed the amount of one month's rent," with listed exceptions such as rent-controlled units and certain senior housing.

  • No last month's rent on top: the Attorney General's tenants' rights guide says a landlord "cannot ask for last month's rent and a security deposit"
  • Same deposit as other tenants: NYCHA's owner guide says an owner "must not collect a higher security deposit than is charged to tenants who are not participants"
  • Deposit vouchers: "Unless exempt, owners must accept security deposit vouchers" (Commission landlord FAQ)

Records to keep

Keep one file per applicant, approved or not. No retention period was found in the sources read. A complaint can be filed with the Commission for one year and in court for three, so VoucherMatch's suggestion is to keep files at least that long.

Records to keep for each applicant
  • The ad as published, and the blank application form
  • The written criteria in force on the application date
  • The fee receipt, the screening company's invoice, and proof the applicant received the report
  • Reference notes: who was called, when, and what was said
  • The credit analysis and the written explanation given
  • The conditional offer, the Fair Chance Housing Notice and the dates each was given
  • Copies of the criminal history sent to the applicant, the five-business-day notice, the applicant's reply, the assessment and the written statement
  • Any adverse action notice
  • The move-in condition agreement, if the tenant asked for the inspection (General Obligations Law 7-108(1-a)(c))
  • Messages with any broker or agent who handled the application

What it means: each record matches a duty cited in this article.

Source: VoucherMatch's list, built from Real Property Law 238-a, Administrative Code 8-107(5)(o), the Commission's landlord FAQ, FTC guidance and General Obligations Law 7-108.

The Benefits of Thorough Screening

Careful screening matters because voucher households stay in the program a long time. NYU's Furman Center found that the median voucher household in New York City had spent 15 years in the program in 2020, against eight years nationally (State of the City 2023). That measures time in the program, not in one apartment.

Renting to Section 8 tenants in NYC weighs the benefits and costs.

Resources

Check any screening rule against the statute or the agency's own page before using it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the housing authority screen Section 8 tenants for landlords? No. The agency checks program eligibility, and federal rules make screening and selection the owner's responsibility.

Is there a Section 8 background check, and can a landlord see it? The agency runs its own check for program rules.

  • NYCHA: its plan says it "does not provide this information to owners"

Can a landlord require 3x the rent in income from a Section 8 tenant? No, according to the Commission on Human Rights, where the program sets the tenant's share from income.

  • Either measure: against the full rent or against the tenant's share
  • Guarantors: may not be required

Can a landlord run a credit check on a Section 8 applicant in NYC? Only where the tenant pays part of the rent, and without a required score. The Commission's wording is under Step 3.

Can a landlord deny a Section 8 applicant in NYC? Yes, for a documented reason that is not the voucher and not one of the barred grounds.

Can a landlord run a criminal background check on a Section 8 tenant? Only after a written conditional offer and the City's notice, and only for reviewable convictions: registry offenses, felonies within five years, misdemeanors within three.

Does an eviction on someone's record mean they lost their Section 8 voucher? No. Federal rules require an agency to end assistance after an eviction from a voucher-assisted home "for serious violation of the lease" (24 CFR 982.552(b)(2)). Other evictions do not trigger that requirement.

  • Screening: Real Property Law 227-f bars refusing an applicant over a landlord-tenant case

How much can a landlord charge a Section 8 applicant to apply, and for a deposit? The check fee is the actual cost or $20, whichever is less. The deposit is capped at one month's rent.

How this article was checked

Last checked: October 7, 2026, against 24 CFR 982.201, 982.307, 982.313, 982.552 and 982.553 (eCFR); NYC Administrative Code sections 8-102, 8-107(5) and 8-126 and the Commission on Human Rights' FAQs, Fair Chance Housing page and Notice; Real Property Law 227-f and 238-a and General Obligations Law 7-108 (nysenate.gov, read through the r.jina.ai browser engine); the NYCHA and HPD voucher administrative plans; FTC guidance. General information, not legal advice.

Sources for this article (21)
  1. 24 CFR 982.307(a) (ecfr.gov)
  2. 24 CFR 982.201 (ecfr.gov)
  3. 24 CFR 982.553 (ecfr.gov)
  4. NYCHA Administrative Plan (nyc.gov)
  5. HPD Administrative Plan (nyc.gov)
  6. Request for Tenancy Approval, form HUD-52517 (hud.gov)
  7. Administrative Code section 8-107(5)(a) (nyc.gov)
  8. landlord FAQ (nyc.gov)
  9. Real Property Law 238-a(1) (nysenate.gov)
  10. State Division of Human Rights notice (dos.ny.gov)
  11. Real Property Law 227-f (nysenate.gov)
  12. General Obligations Law 7-108(1-a)(a) (nysenate.gov)
  13. tenant FAQ (nyc.gov)
  14. Fair Chance Housing page (nyc.gov)
  15. Fair Chance Housing Notice (nyc.gov)
  16. FTC, Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know (ftc.gov)
  17. tenants' rights guide (ag.ny.gov)
  18. owner guide (nyc.gov)
  19. State of the City 2023 (furmancenter.org)
  20. source of income page (nyc.gov)
  21. 24 CFR 982.552(b)(2) (ecfr.gov)
Share:

Stay Updated on Housing

Get the latest on fair market rents, voucher programs, and finding housing.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.

VoucherMatch Editorial Team

Every rule, date and dollar amount in this article is checked against the agency document it comes from, and the sources are listed above. How VoucherMatch articles are researched and corrected

Find apartments

Listings on VoucherMatch come from landlords who say up front which vouchers they accept.

Related Articles

List Your Property Today

Join hundreds of landlords connecting with qualified voucher holders on VoucherMatch.

Weighing a purchase? The RentalCalcs investment calculators from the VoucherMatch team run cash flow and Section 8 rent for any address, free.